Skip to main content

These former NY Mets players are about to trick someone into a free agent overpay

Who'll get paid way more than he deserves?
ByTim Boyle
Aug 8, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA;  New York Mets center fielder Luis Robert Jr. (88) enters the dugout to play there Pittsburgh Pirates at PNC Park. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images
Aug 8, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; New York Mets center fielder Luis Robert Jr. (88) enters the dugout to play there Pittsburgh Pirates at PNC Park. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The MLB lockout won’t stop teams from overpaying free agents. Some might need to linger unsigned for a little longer than they deserve. However, most true major league free agents should end up with a gig somewhere. This includes former New York Mets players who’ve tricked the front office before.

All trade acquisitions by the Mets, these free agents have enough going for them that’ll have some poor club hoping for the best and opening their wallet a little too much.

These former Mets look ready to get more money than they deserve in free agency

Luis Robert Jr.

Does it matter how much you pay Luis Robert Jr.? He has become a guy whose upside doesn’t seem worth the pain of all of the missing in action he does. It’s not as if Robert sprinkles in day-to-day injuries. And after the Mets carefully led him into the 2026 season only for him to still get hurt, everyone should doubt his ability to ever get through a full season. Even with all of this knowledge, someone is going to pay him a decent enough salary on a one-year deal “just in case” he hits above the low .220s again. He hasn’t finished a season over .230 since 2023. Injuries might not be his only issue after all.

Prediction: $7 million from some team that has trouble attracting free agents like the Miami Marlins

Cedric Mullins

Cedric Mullins was a failed Mets trade deadline addition who somehow managed to convince the Tampa Bay Rays to give him a guarantee of $7 million. This was paid in the form of $6.5 million for his 2026 salary plus a $500K buyout they couldn’t wait to implement this offseason. Mullins hit only .205 for Tampa Bay and would land only 5 plate appearances in their run to the World Series. Because he did field his position incredibly well last year, his salary should stay relatively the same to what he got last winter while a team hopes he can add around 20-30 points to his batting average.

Prediction: $6.5 million again from a team ready to take a step forward like the Los Angeles Angels

Paul Blackburn

Paul Blackurn actually had an incredible 2026 season with the New York Yankees. Worth 3.1 bWAR with a 1.59 ERA, it doesn’t matter how deceptive many of the statistics were or what the expected numbers look like. Blackburn was great for the other New York team and should find himself more suitors than he might deserve this winter. The tricky part for any team is whether or not to commit to him for more than one season. On a one-year deal, you’re probably paying a little more. For two years, you could end up with the pitcher he was on the Mets.

Prediction: A two-year deal from the Yankees worth $15 million

Add us as a preferred source on Google