NY Mets Monday Morning GM: 3 MLB All-Stars David Stearns let slip by this offseason

But hey, we aren't mad about a single one of them tiptoeing past.
Chicago Cubs v New York Yankees
Chicago Cubs v New York Yankees | Jim McIsaac/GettyImages
3 of 3

3) Alex Bregman

Apparently, you can miss a lot of time and still become an All-Star. Alex Bregman appeared in only 53 games for the Boston Red Sox. A strong .298/.380/.546 slash line with 11 home runs plus 18 doubles, his presence as an All-Star in 2025 does admittedly feel a bit strange. It was good, but was it enough?

Bregman was one of those players many always believed the Mets might circle around in the offseason. Rumors were not expansive about their interest in him, led more by fans connecting dots. Even with unanswered questions at third base defensively, the team ultimately decided to forego making major changes on the infield. Pete Alonso was re-signed to a smaller deal than what Bregman got from the Red Sox. They’re paying him $36.66 million this year with the star third baseman having opt outs in each of the next two seasons—a decision that remains anyone’s guess.

If the Mets didn’t pursue Bregman all that heavily this past winter, we shouldn’t expect them to change their thought process if he becomes available again. He’s having a better albeit abbreviated season with the Red Sox in 2025 than he did the last few years with the Houston Astros. He’s nice, in theory, but also aging.

Why we aren’t mad about the Mets not signing him

Alonso brings us way too much joy. It was a matter of having one or the other, despite what Steve Cohen’s wallet suggests. Alonso has been healthy yet again this year and incredible for the Mets. Nobody should be angry about this decision.