Friday is the non-tender deadline in Major League Baseball which means players eligible for arbitration will either be tendered a contract or given the heave-ho overboard. It’s an easy way to get out from a player without having to pay money. The most significant New York Mets player who could be non-tendered is Mark Vientos. He’s out of options, coming off of his second straight season of underperforming, and clearly not what David Stearns desires at any position.
The Mets gave Vientos another shot in 2026 after a disappointing 2025. Why wouldn’t they? He was delightful in 2024 while proving all of his doubters wrong almost from start to finish upon his promotion from the minors.
Unfortunately, Vientos didn’t hit much at all this past year nor did he grow into even a competent defender at first base. It should be easy to drag him to the curb. It’s not.
Non-tendering Mark Vientos isn’t as simple for the Mets as it should be
The non-tender deadline is often a chance to save some cash. That’s why when the deadline comes some pretty good ball players are released. Their teams don’t view them as being worth whatever salary they’d get through arbitration. This is hardly the Vientos issue. MLB Trade Rumors projects him to get $2.4 million. That’s what Steve Cohen calls lunch on a Tuesday.
Financially reasonable, Vientos comes with more benefits. He is controlled through the 2029 season which means the Mets could continue to hope for the best with him while filtering his playing time down. He’s a natural platoon partner at first base for Jared Young, just not as exceptional as the Mets would want him to be. Vientos batted .252/.296/.513 against left-handed pitchers in 2026. Heavy on power and light everywhere else, it’s kind of more in the Plan-C style of what you’d want at such a prominent offensive position.
Vientos could work in some situations. The Mets have positioned themselves poorly to give him an extended look. Jorge Polanco, in particular, makes it harder to justify keeping Vientos around let alone going out and adding more to the payroll. Unless the Mets cut him or Marcus Semien, they can ill-afford to hold onto yet another “wait and see” player like Vientos when the rest of the roster has needs.
Vientos’ on-field performance has given the Mets every reason to cut ties. The possibility of tendering him a deal and either trading or cutting him later on exists so if he remains with the Mets at the end of the day Friday, it’s no sure thing he’s sticking around so hold off on buying those number 27 Mets jerseys for the holiday season.
With every tug to yank him off the Mets roster, there's a suggestion to pull the other way and see if he's capable of returning to his 2024 form. First base remains wide open and DH opportunities will remain present. His massive fall over the last two years have done little to help a trade value which briefly reached a point of becoming near-untouchable. The Mets bought into his success.
Acceptance is the final stage of grief. The Mets might just need to accept Vientos has no future here and scratch their heads when he goes out and hammers 30 home runs for someon eelse.
