Skip to main content

3 free agents the NY Mets will probably need to pass on due to last winter’s mistakes

Two poor offseason additions could prevent the Mets from adding any of these free agents.
ByTim Boyle
Mar 15, 2026; Port St. Lucie, Florida, USA;  New York Mets second baseman Marcus Semien (10) is congratulated by second baseman Jorge Polanco (11) after hitting a solo home run in the first inning against the Toronto Blue Jays at Clover Park. Mandatory Credit: Jim Rassol-Imagn Images
Mar 15, 2026; Port St. Lucie, Florida, USA; New York Mets second baseman Marcus Semien (10) is congratulated by second baseman Jorge Polanco (11) after hitting a solo home run in the first inning against the Toronto Blue Jays at Clover Park. Mandatory Credit: Jim Rassol-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Because most of David Stearns’ mistakes last winter are still present on the New York Mets roster, there’s no escaping the perils they create. Marcus Semien is under contract for two more years and while he should have a reduced role if he fails to perform, it’s hard to see the Mets eating his entire contract until at least one more season. Jorge Polanco’s injury-filled campaign and lack of production doesn’t help matters either. Under contract yet again for the 2027 season, his presence limits the Mets both in terms of payroll and his occupation of a roster spot in an unknown role.

If it hadn’t been for both of those mistakes, the Mets would have a golden opportunity to add more in free agency than we should actually expect. These three available players would make a lot of sense if they had the space available. Alas, we should expect the Mets to give those clinger-ons another chance.

Mistakes from the past will prevent the Mets from signing these players

1) Brandon Lowe

Brandon Lowe went from being a terrible fielding second baseman to one year with the Pittsburgh Pirates that produced a 12 OAA season. He has always been a very good hitter. He has a lifetime .810 OPS with three seasons of mashing over 30 home runs. He clobbed 35 with 96 RBI for the Pirates last season.

Lowe doesn’t seem likely to end up with the Mets for a couple of reasons. He received and has declined the qualifying offer from the Pirates which would have already made him a questionable addition in the first place. Capable of playing second base (apparently well now) or even first base for the Mets, he’s someone we’d love to see in blue and orange but definitely won’t.

2) Luis Arraez

The story was somewhat the same with Luis Arraez. The big knock on him was always his defense as well as his lack of ability to do much else other than make contact and win batting titles in his sleep. With the San Francisco Giants, Arraez became a 10 OAA defender. He finished the season with the Philadelphia Phillies while hitting a light .310 overall.

Arraez’s defensive growth out of nowhere suddenly makes him more desirable in free agency than if he was the below-average infielder he had been many times in the past. Of course, defense can fluctuate as much as anything for players from year-to-year. Arraez would have the same capabilities as Lowe, only with much different expectations. Lowe is a power-hitter who’ll K a bunch but drive in runs. You ask Arraez to put the ball in play. Because of the design of the Mets roster, he seems equally as unlikely to come to the Mets.

3) Ty France

There are a lot of reasons why I don’t think Ty France ends up with the Mets. With all due respect, nobody should believe he replicates what he did with the San Diego Padres last season. France will get at least a three-year deal and should push for a fourth season. Earning in the ballpark of $15-16 million per year, he’s a better buy than what Polanco ended up being.

It’s Polanco and his undefined role as a DH, possible first baseman holding the Mets back even more than Semien when it comes to adding to the offense. It’s not as simple as cutting Polanco either. The Mets have shown there is a limit on the spending. We’re probably more likely to get Paul Goldschmidt, Alec Bohm, or a potential trade piece added instead.

Add us as a preferred source on Google