Future NY Mets infielder logjam will require tough choices

Spring training for the New York Mets has been a battleground, with numerous position battles vying for attention. While the starting rotation and bullpen configurations garnered headlines, one of the most intriguing contests was for the final infield bench spot.

The emergence of Brett Baty, showcasing an improved approach at the plate and surprising comfort at second base, clashed with the dynamic versatility and speed of Luisangel Acuña. Both players entered camp with high expectations, aiming to secure a place on the Opening Day roster.

Jeff McNeil's return creates a roster dilemma

Jeff McNeil’s low-grade right oblique strain solidified Baty and Acuña's chances of breaking camp with the team. But when McNeil returns, the Mets will face a critical decision of who stays, and who goes back to Triple-A.

Right now, in the Mets Opening Day roster, the initial scenario could envision a possible platoon situation, with both Baty and Acuña splitting time. Acuña’s speed and defensive prowess would have been valuable late-game assets, particularly in close contests. However, with McNeil’s imminent return, the Mets must confront the reality of a roster crunch. One of these promising young infielders will likely be heading to Triple-A Syracuse.

If both Baty and Acuña perform well in the early weeks of the season, the determining factor should be defensive versatility and speed. While Baty’s offensive potential is undeniable, the Mets’ needs extend beyond sheer hitting ability. The team requires a player capable of covering multiple infield positions with above-average defense, including shortstop.

This emphasis on shortstop versatility stems from the Mets’ desire to manage Francisco Lindor’s workload. Resting their star shortstop periodically is crucial to maintaining his health and preventing late-season fatigue. Acuña, with his athleticism and experience at shortstop, provides that necessary flexibility.

Choosing Acuña over Baty, despite the latter's potential offensive surge, might seem like a less glamorous option. But considering the Mets' current roster construction the team needs a player who can contribute in multiple ways. A versatile infielder with speed can be a game-changer, providing crucial late-game defensive replacements and creating havoc on the basepaths in critical situations.

Ultimately, the decision rests on prioritizing the team’s overall needs. While Baty’s bat is enticing, Acuña’s defensive versatility and speed align more closely with the Mets’ strategy of building a well-rounded and adaptable roster.