Solving the Mark Vientos conundrum has been a years-long New York Mets endeavor. The team has tried everything to get the once-promising slugger going, most notably trying to hide his porous glove at first base, to no avail. At this point, the 27-year-old may find himself on the non-tender block.
Before getting to that point, the Mets would love to extract some value from a player who was once a highly-thought-of asset. Some might believe that they now have their chance. Former Philadelphia Phillies third baseman Alec Bohm, who some felt could be a fit for the Mets, has seen his market heat up as several teams have been rumored in connection with him on the free-agent market.
It's easy to draw parallels between Bohm and Vientos. Both are coming off down years, with Bohm hitting .249/.315/.383 with 15 homers over 155 games and Vientos slashing .212/.258/.394 with 13 homers in 87 contests. Both players hit right-handed, play a poor third base, and were moved, at least partially, to first but had little defensive success.
Given the similarities, it's easy to assume that a team interested in Bohm would then be interested in Vientos. In fact, you might believe that Vientos might be the better option, given that Bohm's price is likely to be driven up on the open market, while the much-maligned Met is projected to make just $2.4 million in arbitration, per MLB Trade Rumors.
However, that assumes that Vientos provides what teams are hoping to receive from Bohm, and that isn't really the case.
Alec Bohm's surprising market demand won't raise trade interest for Mets Mark Vientos due to differences in skill sets
Vientos at his best is a prototypical power hitter. Even in a down year in 2026, he produced a .182 ISO. That's higher than Bohm's career-best of .168 from 2024, and markedly better than the .134 mark this year. Vientos' career-high ISO came in at .249 during his sterling 2024 campaign when he crushed 27 homers over just 111 games and batted .266/.322/.516.
Bohm, however, is much better at making contact. In 2026, his overall contact rate was 84.9%, with a superb 90.4% zone contact rate. Vientos managed a contact rate of 70.1% and a zone contact rate of 81.1% this year. Because of that, we've seen Bohm post higher batting averages. Throughout his career, he has hit .280 or better in three of the full seasons he has played, and owns a career batting average of .273. Vientos has never hit better than .266 and is a .234 career hitter.
This manifests itself in strikeouts, too. Bohm's career strikeout rate is 17%, and he struck out at a 14% clip in 2026. Vientos has improved from the near-30% rate he averaged at the beginning of his career, but he still struck out 24.1% of the time this year, and 27.2% for his career.
So while power is the No. 1 most important skill for a hitter, teams are starting to realize that selling out entirely for it can be detrimental. Take the New York Yankees, for example. Over the largest swath of time that Aaron Judge missed, from June 1 through September 7, they collectively hit just .227, ranking 29th in baseball.
https://t.co/PnPxGpepZB Yankees are looking closely at 3B Alec Bohm, a nice righty bat who finished very strongly and rakes vs. lefties
— Jon Heyman (@JonHeyman) November 11, 2026
They're far from unique. The Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays tied for the best team batting average in baseball this year at .258. They played each other in the World Series. Correlation does not equal causation, but it's clear there was some influence here.
So, if you're a club shopping in the Alec Bohm market, you're hoping to get a high-contact hitter who can hit .280 with 15-20 homers a year. Mark Vientos isn't going to provide that, and therefore, he'd be of no interest to you.
The unfortunate reality for the Mets, then, is that there is no way to ride the Bohm wave and collect a useful asset for Vientos. He might end up on the non-tender pile, but New York can trade him; the club will find they won't get anything more than a lottery ticket in return. Something is better than nothing, though, right?
