2 Mets trade deadline home runs, 2 swings and misses

The New York Mets trade deadline was a strange one where you can feel pleased but also unsatisfied at the same time. It’s like getting the wrong flavor of ice cream on a hot day. It’s still ice cream at the end of the day.

Did the Mets get better? They definitely did. Could they have come out of the trade deadline even mightier? Absolutely.

In two plate appearances the Mets hit a home run. In two others, they swung and missed hard.

The Mets hit a home run with their bullpen depth additions

Ryne Stanek and Phil Maton were the two early additions to the bullpen. They’ll be permanent fixtures in the bullpen. But the Mets didn’t stop there. Tyler Zuber and Huascar Brazoban will give them additional and optional depth. The Mets came out of the trade deadline stacked with relief pitchers and not just guys who’ll be on the immediate roster bubble.

Although the Mets didn’t pay the piper for any of the major relief pitcher trade targets, coming away with players like Zuber and Brazoban who have control beyond this year as well helped give them a head start on the 2025 season as well.

The Mets couldn’t have done much better in the bullpen without sacrificing a major prospect. As desirable as players like Tanner Scott were, the San Diego Padres gave up their firstborn to get him.

The Mets hit a home run by not overpaying in a buyer’s market

Not a single one of the trades the Mets made felt like they overpaid. Each was a one prospect for one player deal. None of the prospects were highly ranked. Unless you’ve been locked in on Mets minor leaguers this season and last, you probably had to do a little more research on the guys they did give up.

David Stearns’ behavior at the trade deadline was reminiscent of William Wallace in Braveheart yelling “Hold!” As the camera cuts to the charging English soldiers on horseback then back to Wallace again, the tension builds yet he continues to tell his men to “Hold!”

The Mets resisted temptation. Mets prospect lovers rejoiced. Other fans might have felt like they bit into one of those sour Warhead candies from the 1990s. Wasn’t it the blue one that could bring tears?

Stearns had a mission when coming to the Mets and it was to act responsibly. He achieved this. The Mets improved and the only cost they gave were prospects who need a bit more work to become any danger of turning into star players.

How would we feel if the Mets gave up as much as the San Diego Padres did for Jason Adam and Tanner Scott? The Mets weren’t two big relief pitchers away from being World Series favorites. Stearns took a more practical approach and are capable of having just as good of a bullpen as their fellow NL Wild Card contender.

The Mets swung and missed by not flexing their financial might

Other teams are onto the Mets. Discussion leading into the trade deadline was how the Mets would use Steve Cohen’s financial wealth to their advantage. They failed here. Outside of the early July trade for Phil Maton, there was nothing money-driven about the moves they made. Did Cohen get cold feet? Or maybe teams are no longer so tempted to make such moves with a team that has a weapon like this.

It’s different with a buyer than a seller. The Houston Astros and Texas Rangers set themselves up to try and go for a championship last year with the two moves they made with the Mets. It would be different for the Detroit Tigers to let the Mets pay Javier Baez if it rewarded them Tarik Skubal. Other, less ridiculous scenarios, never came to fruition either. We all wondered about the possibility of the Mets getting Blake Snell on the cheap. As it turns out, the San Francisco Giants are trying to compete while also selling some parts away.

The MLB trade deadline ain’t what it used to be.

The offseason is when the Mets having the richest owner in the sport matters most. Other clubs are into their game. A creative thinker like Stearns paired with Cohen is tough to match. When the Mets are making a move like selling players and paying their contracts, teams will bite. When they’re looking to win baseball games and provide salary relief, there’s still a price to pay.

We shouldn’t begrudge the Mets for swinging and missing here. Use this as a wakeup call. 

Thank goodness there’s always the waiver wire in August when plenty of big contracts will make their way there. Perhaps sliding down the standings and moving up the waiver wire wouldn’t be such a bad thing in the last week of August.