Ranking 5 realistic options at third base for the Mets in 2024

The New York Mets are facing a critical year in 2024. After the 2023 campaign crashed and burned, it's critical to show that the team is moving in the right direction. There will be many new faces in Flushing, and with the demotion of Brett Baty to AAA this week, third base will be a hot topic heading into the offseason. Will the Mets supplement the position in free agency, or look from within the organization for the answer?

It's important to keep in mind that for as fat as Mets owner Steve Cohen's wallet is, there is a limit to his willingness to spend, especially after last offseason's spending spree resulted in such a disappointing season. Any money spent on third base could potentially limit the Mets' ability to splurge on the team's most essential area of need, starting pitching.

Let's also not forget that even though Francisco Lindor, Brandon Nimmo, Jeff McNeil, and Edwin Diaz are locked up long term, Pete Alonso is going to command a huge contract when he hits the market next year. Extending Alonso this offseason would lock up the entire Mets core, preventing a lame duck season in which rumors, and therefore distractions, would swirl around the team all year. Pete's pending payday also has to be factored into any potential third base signing.

Let's get into the possibilities, which we'll rank from worst to best.

5) Ronny Mauricio emerges as the Mets third baseman

There's a lot to be excited about when it comes to Mauricio. He has power and speed, and he has a slash line of .287/.336/.483 at AAA Syracuse this year. Following Baty's demotion, it was reported that Mauricio would begin taking reps at third base, a position he hasn't played before. Does this concern anyone else?

Third base is one of the most demanding defensive positions on the diamond. There's a reason it's called the hot corner. Mauricio has bounced from shortstop, to second base, to left field, and now to third. That doesn't inspire confidence.

Also of importance is that although Mauricio has been hyped up as the next great Mets prospect, Brett Baty spent his minor league career ranked more highly within the Mets system. Giving Baty a year before giving up on him for a guy that has never been thought of as highly seems rash.

Mets fans have been clamoring for Mauricio to get called up all year. At this point, if he's anything short of a combination of David Wright and Jose Reyes, it will be a disappointment. Handing him the starting job, at a position he isn't familiar with, on a team that is trying to rinse the bad taste of 2023 out of its mouth, in a city that puts more pressure on its players than any other, is a recipe for disaster.

We'd love to see Mauricio on the Opening Day roster next year, but let's ease him into things before throwing him into the fire.

4) Matt Chapman signs a long-term deal to be the Mets third baseman

This ranking is not a knock on Matt Chapman, an All-Star caliber player that would fit fantastically onto this roster, both in the lineup and in the field. Instead, this is a knock on the money it would take to sign Matt Chapman. As we've mentioned before, Chapman is projected by Bleacher Report to sign this offseason for something in the range of six years, $180 million.

The Mets are paying the likes of Justin Verlander, Max Scherzer, and others more money to play for other teams than some teams are paying for its entire roster. While this is evidence that certain small market owners should find a new hobby where they actually spend their billions of dollars instead of holding entire cities hostage with their miserly ways, it doesn't change the fact that Steve Cohen has a limit to how much cash he wants to set on fire.

If the Mets do nothing at all to address their starting pitching in free agency, their starting rotation in 2024 will be Kodai Senga, Jose Quintana, Tylor Megill, David Peterson, and Cow-Bell Man. For Mets fans that have suffered most of their lives, this is a bridge too far. At minimum, two quality starters from free agency need to be brought in, and you could very easily talk me into Mike Vasil rounding things out by making the jump to the majors.

Going after the likes of Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Julio Urias, Aaron Nola, and others will not be cheap. Matt Chapman will be very good for some team in 2024 and beyond, but he can only help the Mets so much if they have no pitching.

3) Brett Baty takes back his job as the Mets third baseman

Baty's recent demotion and continued mediocre play doesn't inspire confidence that he should be penciled in every day on the 2024 Mets lineup. Hopefully he finishes the season strong, whether that be in AAA or with a call up later in the year, but even then, he won't have shown enough to have earned a stranglehold on the job.

Baty's numbers against lefties are the primary reason why he can't yet be trusted to play every day. He's struck out in exactly one third of his at-bats against southpaws, while managing only a single home run and a paltry .159 batting average.

More than any other sport, the major league baseball season is a grind. While the NFL plays just once a week and the NBA has embraced the concept of load management, baseball is still mostly stuck in the old school mindset (pitch counts notwithstanding) of players playing nearly every day. With a season that stretches from April through October, 162 games takes its toll, especially on young players.

Baty will enter next year more prepared for the wear and tear of a full season in the big leagues, but it would behoove the Mets to not put too much on his plate. Buck Showalter called Baty's demotion "just a little timeout" and a "reset". This shows that the Mets still have faith that he can figure things out.

For every Francisco Alvarez and Corbin Carroll that are established as franchise players in their rookie seasons, countless others take longer to become quality major leaguers. It's unfair to expect Baty to be an All-Star right away, but his future is still bright.

2) Justin Turner returns to the Mets for a platoon with Brett Baty

Turner hasn't played for the Mets since 2013, but in the time since he has made a career of being one of the best offensive third basemen in the game. Currently playing for the Red Sox, he's still raking at age 38.

With Rafael Devers locked in as the Red Sox third baseman, Turner has only played seven games at the hot corner this year, but he's plugged in wherever the Red Sox need him, whether that be at DH, second base, or first base. That kind of versatility is something any team could use.

It's worth noting that Turner has a $13.4 million player option for next year, but with the Red Sox just barely staying relevant in the playoff race, he may be looking for a fresh start elsewhere. The Mets would be a perfect fit. Turner has hit over .280 against both righties and lefties this year, with an OPS of over .900 against lefties.

Adding Turner would unlock all kinds of possibilities for the Mets. When Baty starts at third, Turner can DH or play at second. This could move Jeff McNeil to the outfield, opening spots for Ronny Mauricio or Mark Vientos in the lineup.

Evan Longoria is another veteran possibility to platoon with Baty, but Turner gets the nod because of his versatility and durability. Longoria has played in only 55 games for the Diamondbacks this year, and hasn't hit 100 games since 2019. Turner has played in 105 of a possible 113 games for the Red Sox, and outside of the shortened 2020 season, has played in over 100 games every year since 2014.