Mets delivered a deathblow to these 3 teams who could have used Brandon Nimmo
Bringing back Brandon Nimmo was the most obvious move for the New York Mets to make. The center field market was dry. Outside of a trade or trying to move Starling Marte there and finding a new right fielder, it didn’t seem like the club had too many options.
Nimmo was an incredibly popular player on the free agent market which is one of the reasons why the Mets had to blow him out of the water with an 8-year deal worth $162 million.
As the dust settles, a few teams are now left scratching their heads as to what they do next. The Mets delivered a deathblow to a couple of clubs when they went above and beyond to retain Nimmo.
1) NY Mets killed the Blue Jays' plan by re-signing Brandon Nimmo
The Toronto Blue Jays were gearing up to bring Nimmo to Canada. Trading Teoscar Hernandez cleared one roster spot for them to move George Springer to the corner and bring in a younger center field option. No dice.
The Blue Jays could have used Nimmo for more than just his center field prowess. Their lineup is so right-handed you’d swear it was built by people who still believe the left hand represents evil. Nimmo could have given their mostly young lineup a spark at the top. Now they’ll need to turn elsewhere to find some more chi in the lineup.
Knowing Nimmo as we do, Toronto didn’t seem to line up so greatly with his beliefs. A change in the country’s vaccination requirements could have put the Blue Jays in a real pickle. We can only speculate about how Nimmo would have felt going to them as he is, fortunately, not outspoken politically. He’s just a happy guy about to get paid a lot more money by the Mets.
2) NY Mets ruined an Aaron Judge backup plan for the SF Giants
When Aaron Judge went back to the New York Yankees, the San Francisco Giants must have felt the urgency to make a move. Mitch Haniger ain’t gettin’ it done. Nimmo plus two more additions to the lineup might start to look pretty good. It won’t be happening because the Mets swooped in.
The Giants have an almost laughable starting lineup right now. J.D. Davis is expected to hit in the middle of it. Our dear friend Wilmer Flores will have a vital role, too. Their lineup construction is unbelievably weak. They somehow made something similar work in 2021 when they won the division. However, any holdovers from that season have gotten older and regressed further. Brandon Crawford looks cooked.
San Francisco has players they can look at to make up for the loss of Judge. Nimmo was the second-best outfielder in free agency. It might be time to consider making a trade.
For those teams out on the West Coast, one has to wonder if there is some sort of mass exodus because of the California tax. Trea Turner turned down a bigger offer from the San Diego Padres to join the Philadelphia Phillies. They were also snubbed by Judge. Meanwhile, even the Los Angeles Dodgers have remained relatively quiet. The Padres did end up with Xander Bogaerts, but on a deal that far exceeded anything the Boston Red Sox were willing to pony up.
The real messaging to get across here: the Mets 1, Giants 0.
3) NY Mets destroyed the “hometown discount” the Rockies were hoping for
The Colorado Rockies were one of the early teams rumored to have an interest in signing Nimmo. Them? The one team that didn’t make a single move at the MLB trade deadline this past summer? The directionless Rockies who trade Nolan Arenado then go out and pay Kris Bryant a ridiculous amount more not long after?
It’s those Rockies we’re talking about.
Colorado would have been a place where we’d expect Nimmo to absolutely destroy his career averages. Coors Field would have made him an immediate All-Star. On what could have been a semi-hometown discount for the Wyoming native, there was some early fear that the Rockies could overpay for Nimmo and he’d expect just to be closer to home.
Money prevailed. The Mets weren’t willing to get outbid and lose another homegrown player to a sub-.500 baseball team from last season. Jacob deGrom going to the Texas Rangers, a team that does seem to have a purpose, isn’t quite as illogical as the second best free agent outfielder signing with the Rockies.
Colorado will now look at some lesser options for the position, including their current top candidate Yonathan Diaz. He has hit well over the past two years in a limited role. The .304 batting average at home and .260 on the road suggests partly why that is.
The Rockies will now need a new plan if they hope to spend.