Sean Manaea signing puts these 3 Mets players in danger of getting booted from the 40-man roster

Jul 29, 2023; New York City, New York, USA; New York Mets relief pitcher Reed Garrett (75) delivers
Jul 29, 2023; New York City, New York, USA; New York Mets relief pitcher Reed Garrett (75) delivers / Vincent Carchietta-USA TODAY Sports
3 of 3
Next

The New York Mets signed Sean Manaea to a two-year deal to provide a much-needed boost to the rotation. Manaea joins Adrian Houser and Luis Severino as external additions the team made this offseason to put into the rotation which already had Kodai Senga and Jose Quintana.

The Manaea signing makes sense as a player who took a short-term deal, filled a need, and has some upside. The Mets aren't going as all-in as they have in recent years, but expect to be somewhat competitive in 2024. Manaea undoubtedly gets them closer.

While the Manaea signing likely puts the finishing touches on the Mets rotation, it also puts the Mets over the limit on their 40-man roster. Their 40-man had reached 40 players after the Harrison Bader signing became official. With that in mind, these three players could have their spots on the 40-man be in jeopardy for when Manaea's deal becomes official.

1) Reed Garrett

As the Mets continued to search for bullpen depth last season, they claimed Reed Garrett off of waivers from the Orioles. Garrett hadn't done much in his 23 MLB appearances before debuting with the Mets, and he remained a subpar option whenever he was called upon.

In his nine appearances with the Mets this past season, Garrett allowed 11 runs in 17 innings pitched. He had some good outings, including delivering three scoreless innings against the Phillies in Game 161 of the season, and some bad ones as well. He showed some value as an innings eater, but with the Mets signing Michael Tonkin to work as a long relief option in the 'pen,

What might keep Garrett on the 40-man roster is the fact that he does have a minor league option available. This gives the Mets the ability to send him up and down from the majors to the minors.

While relievers with options have value, ones who boast a career ERA of 6.41 do not. In all likelihood Garrett would pass through waivers, and on the off-chance that he doesn't, it wouldn't be a big loss anyway.

2) Sean Reid-Foley

Sean Reid-Foley is the only member of the Steven Matz trade still with his respective team, but that might not last for very long. The right-hander has had short stints for the Mets in each of the last three seasons but Tommy John Surgery limited his action substantially, and his 4.93 ERA in 27 Mets appearances makes him very expendable.

Reid-Foley has some value as a long reliever, but again, the Mets appear set in that regard with Tonkin and several other starting pitchers who can work out of the bullpen.

While Garrett likely has no path to the Mets Opening Day roster, Reid-Foley is a player who is out of options. If the Mets believe he's worth keeping around he's going to make the team, but the problem is, he's shown no reason to be prioritized over some of the other relievers the team just brought in who also don't have options.

The 28-year-old is another example of a reliever who will presumably clear waivers if he were to get DFA'd. He's also another example of a player the Mets wouldn't exactly miss if he didn't clear waivers.

3) Zack Short

Garrett and Reid-Foley were both in the organization last season, giving reason to believe David Stearns might see no value in retaining them. Zack Short, on the other hand, was picked up by David Stearns this offseason off of waivers.

Short being claimed by Stearns and being out of options gave him the slightest chance to potentially make the team out of Spring Training, but the way this Mets roster is shaping up, that seems highly unlikely.

The Mets signed Joey Wendle to be their backup infielder. Wendle has slowed down offensively, but has good speed and plays excellent defense at multiple positions. Short is the same type of player, as he has just a .575 career OPS but is a fast runner who has played solid defense at three different infield positions.

Wendle being on the roster makes Short very expendable. The Mets can part with him and not really worry about him clearing waivers or not. If he does, he's fine depth to have. If he doesn't, the Mets already have a better version of himself on the MLB roster.

manual

Next