3 prospects the Mets should have protected from the Rule 5 Draft

The Mets might lose three top-30 organizational prospects in the Rule 5 Draft

Aug 8, 2023; Bridgewater, NJ; Mets' new minor league prospect Jeremiah Jackson is shown at TD Bank
Aug 8, 2023; Bridgewater, NJ; Mets' new minor league prospect Jeremiah Jackson is shown at TD Bank / Anne-Marie Caruso/NorthJersey.com / USA
3 of 3
Next

The Rule 5 Draft gives teams the opportunity to find hidden gems that other organizations might not believe in very strongly. The New York Mets haven't picked many notable players, but players like Ryan Pressly and Garrett Whitlock are among notable names selected in the last decade.

In order to protect prospects from being selected in the Rule 5 Draft, teams add prospects eligible for it onto their 40-man roster. The Mets did this with former top prospect Alex Ramirez. While Ramirez has obvious upside, it was definitely a bit surprising to see him added as players selected have to stay on the 26-man active roster all season long. This would make a player like Ramirez who struggled in A+ Brooklyn this season an unlikely player to be selected.

Ramirez was the only player added to New York's 40-man roster, but should that should not have been the case. Here are three players the Mets should have protected from being selected in the Rule 5 Draft by being added to their 40-man roster.

1) Jeremiah Jackson

The Mets acquired Jeremiah Jackson in the trade that sent Dominic Leone to the Angels. The Mets getting anything for Leone was surprising, and landing someone that actually looked like a decent prospect was shocking.

Jackson was in the midst of a decent year for AA Rocket City in the Angels organization before the trade, but elevated his game in the Mets system after he was acquired. The 23-year-old slashed .264/.344/.457 with seven home runs and 24 RBI for AA Binghamton. He's far from perfect as his 50 strikeouts in 37 games for Binghamton would indicate, but he showed flashes of being a really solid player.

What's most exciting about Jackson is his positional versatility. This season alone, Jackson played five different positions and that's not including the five games he appeared in as a DH. He's primarily a middle infielder, but also played third base and both corner outfield positions. He looks like a player with a real MLB future as a utility player off the bench.

It was pretty surprising to see the Mets risk losing the 23-year-old to the draft as there's a pretty good chance a team out there will take a flier on him with that versatility in mind.

2) Coleman Crow

While Jackson took off in the Mets organization after the team acquired him, Crow has yet to appear in a game in the Mets minor league system. He underwent Tommy John Surgery which knocked him out for this season with the exception of just four starts, and could miss all of next season as well.

Crow's injury might make some think teams will avoid him, but I actually think it'll be the exact opposite. This gives opposing teams the opportunity to stash him essentially for free.

In the offseason, the 60-day IL does not exist. Everyone who was on the 60-day IL has to be added to the 40-man roster. While that's how things work in the offseason, players on the 60-day IL do not have to be on the 40-man roster once Spring Training begins. With Crow likely out for the entire season, if a team selects him he can just spend the year in which he'd have to be on the MLB roster on the IL and then resume pitching in the minor leagues in 2025.

The Mets have 33 players on their 40-man roster after adding Jackson. They had plenty of room to add Crow throughout the offseason, and on the off-chance that they don't, they could've traded or waived him if they wanted to use him to open a spot.

The 22-year-old is far from a household name as he ranks 29th on the Mets prospect list according to MLB Pipeline, but he clearly has some value as he was the main player the Mets received in the Eduardo Escobar trade and is one of the organization's top 30 prospects. It's possible he goes unclaimed, but this feels like roster mismanagement.

3) Justin Jarvis

Justin Jarvis is yet another player the Mets traded for this past season, as the team acquired him in exchange for Mark Canha in a one-for-one deal. While Canha flourished for Milwaukee, Jarvis had his struggles for the Mets posting an 8.04 ERA in nine starts for AAA Syracuse.

It should be noted that the man responsible for acquiring all three of these prospects, Billy Eppler is no longer with the organization. Despite that, Jarvis felt like a player David Stearns was going to protect because of their Milwaukee connection.

Stearns selected Jarvis in the fifth round of the 2018 MLB Draft, and Jarvis remained with the Brewers for several years while Stearns was in charge.

Another reason Jarvis' omission was a bit surprising is the fact that he's ranked 15th on the Mets prospect list. Prospect lists aren't everything, but there are reasons why he's ranked where he is and why the Mets felt good enough to trade Mark Canha for him alone.

With how poorly Jarvis did in AAA it's certainly possible he doesn't get selected, but the Mets feeling the need to protect Alex Ramirez who had struggles of his own at a much lower level and not Jarvis who is clearly more advanced.

There's a chance none of these players get selected, and there's an even bigger chance none of these players are super impactful. Despite that, it was surprising and disappointing to leave some talented players available to be selected by other teams when they had a ton of 40-man roster space.

manual

Next