3 average Mets free agent signings that deserve an extreme re-grade

There were some extreme opinions about the New York Mets this offseason. A much more underwhelming group brought in through free agency than we saw in recent seasons, it was easy to get caught up in thinking the club wouldn’t be that good.

In actuality, they’re somewhere in the middle. They’re a few lucky bounces or unfortunate runs away from either being buried in the playoff race or being awarded a chance to play deep into October.

In the days leading up to the start of the regular season, all fans have their thoughts as to what grade certain moves deserve. Now about 25% into the season already, these three free agent signings already deserve a much different grade than they originally had.

1) Jorge Lopez

Signed for just $2 million, the Mets were taking a bit of a chance on Jorge Lopez. By far best known as the All-Star closer no one saw coming for the Baltimore Orioles in 2022, he has been average or worse in so many other seasons of his career. Even after the miraculous All-Star performance for the Orioles two seasons ago, Lopez reverted back to his old ways immediately after getting traded to the Minnesota Twins. His ERA jumped from 1.68 to 4.37. In 2023, it was at 5.95 which isn’t all that much worse than where he has been for his entire career.

The Lopez signing took place early in the offseason. As affordable as it was, the roster spot and $2 million could’ve been better used elsewhere. Or so it seemed.

Old Grade: C-

The ability to DFA Lopez if things didn’t work out without much of a financial burden like they did with Michael Tonkin twice had this as an acceptable offseason signing. However, Lopez hasn’t just been a mound-filler. He has been an important part of the bullpen.

Lopez is one of the few pitchers who hasn’t won or lost a game. Yet he leads the relievers in appearances by a good margin with 21 games. It’s five more than Edwin Diaz, Adam Ottavino, and Jake Diekman who’ve each appeared in 16.

Lopez hasn’t been a major strikeout pitcher but with zero home runs allowed this year, we get a good understanding of what has made him so useful. 

New Grade: A

2) Joey Wendle

Unfortunately, not many of the Mets free agent signings have seen their grade improve. Luis Severino and Sean Manaea have been good but the grade change doesn’t seem so drastic. They go from what, a C up to a B+ or so?

On the other hand, the free agent signing of Joey Wendle has dropped off much more than anticipated. His numbers aren’t disastrous. It’s his failure to do the little things well like play defense or even get down a sacrifice bunt that has aggravated the fans.

Signed for just $2 million this offseason, he seemed like a decent pickup. In a lesser role, he appeared to be a solid upgrade over Luis Guillorme. The Mets could turn to him for help at any infield position. What was there to really dislike about it?

Old Grade: C+

The doubts began early when before the year even began the Wendle contract looked like an overpay. Gio Urshela got $500K less to sign with the Detroit Tigers. A far better fit for the Mets, it didn’t take long for Wendle’s performance to match those same doubts.

Any of the numbers Wendle does have feel a bit hollow considering how badly he has missed on defense at times. His two error game felt like the final straw for most fans. The front office didn’t disagree. Needing some sort of spark in the offense, they designated him for assignment on May 14.

Wendle will head into DFA limbo with a .222/.243/.250 slash line and 3 errors in only a small number of games. Temporarily, the Mets will choose to have no middle infield backup than him.

New Grade: D-