3 players in which the Mets either failed, are failing, or will fail and mismanage

New York Mets v New York Yankees
New York Mets v New York Yankees / Jim McIsaac/GettyImages
2 of 3
Next

Not all talents have turned into roses for the New York Mets. In fact, it has probably been the team's undoing of one's potential with the team that has hurt more.

We last wrote on this topic two years ago on 3 players whom the Mets had failed or mishandled, such as original 1962 Met Ed Kranepool and recent Met Kirk Nieuwenhuis.

Seth Lugo has always wanted to start, but the New York Mets rarely felt the need to put him in the rotation.

Seth Lugo came onto the scene for the Mets in 2016 when he helped a rotation decimated with injuries and dominated. His performance was one of the main reasons the team made the playoffs as a wild card team that year.

And after an okay 2017 season, he was moved to the bullpen nearly full-time in 2018 and 2019 and was sensational. But it was Lugo's desire to start in the majors going back five years now and he deserved a chance in such a role.

Instead, the Mets decided to add starting pitching from outside the organization after Zach Wheeler left, and they got two massive busts in New York with Michael Wacha and Rick Porcello. And then Carlos Carrasco, who wasn't great in 2021, but was good last year, and not so much early on here this season.

This caused Lugo to search outside the Mets for a chance to be a full-time starter after the Mets conditioned him as a (really good) reliever for half a decade, and several teams expressed interest in signing him.

The San Diego Padres signed him because they had to address their rotation, and he killed it in his first two starts, giving up just two runs in 13 innings pitched. The Mets should be kicking themselves after seeing him go and the lack of depth the Mets have in their pitching staff.

Brett Baty should be raking for the New York Mets, not the Syracuse Mets.

Brett Baty is 9-of-27 with 3 home runs and a 1.196 OPS this season... for Triple-A Syracuse. Oh.... oh good! And Eduardo Escobar... just .103 and 1 home run... for the New York Mets. That's a problem.

And we're seeing first hand the mistake the Mets made not letting Brett Baty make the team. It feels like the third baseman is an automatic out in the Mets lineup. This is an easy first guess, and anyone could have seen it from far away.

Baty could have used an opportunity to test his eye discipline against the Marlins. There is also the opportunity coming up against Oakland's anemic pitching this weekend to get some good stats in and against the Dodgers next week to test him against world class pitching, so Mets fans should hope that Baty continues his success in Triple-A to force Billy Eppler's hand here.

Perhaps Eppler is being extra cautious with Baty because Alvarez struggled in his first two games in the majors and they want to season Baty a bit, but still that's no excuse.

But, you know, the Mets feel like they have to justify the Eduardo Escobar contract and paying him eight figures this year.

The New York Mets' early usage of John Curtiss in his first action off Tommy John surgery is concerning.

John Curtiss has pitched well to start his Mets career delayed by a year due to Tommy John surgery, He gave up just one run in five relief appearances over his first two weeks, but it feels like it may not last, due to some inconsistencies in his career, and how this feels overtaxed.

The Mets' rotation has been concerning to start, as they are not going deep enough in games, and it has forced Buck Showalter's hand in terms of middle relievers whom they can trust to eat innings, and overuse other guys in their bullpen too, as they've been the first two weeks. If Trevor Williams was re-signed, he would have been the guy to fill such a role. But he's not here anymore. So this leaves someone other than Brooks Raley, David Robertson, Adam Ottavino, and others to get the job done, and that responsibility fell on Curtiss.

Curtiss not pitching the last two games in the Padres series and the day off on Thursday may be a welcome respite, but the Mets play 10 days in a row starting on Friday in California, and I believe he will be needed to get big outs in the fifth or sixth innings of games, and given how hot the Dodgers and Giants offenses have been to start, it may be too much to handle for when the wear and tear of the season gets to them later on.

3 trades we would already like to see the Mets get done. dark. Next

Next