2 bold Mets strategies that'll work out well in 2024, 1 that'll be a failure
Using what he did with the Milwaukee Brewers, New York Mets fans have tried all offseason to predict what David Stearns values most. The situation is much different than it was in Milwaukee. In fact, one could argue the Mets are in a spot very few teams ever get to. They have so much dead money on the books and yet they aren’t completely punting on the season. There’s a little bit of purgatory they’re stuck in; hopefully not for too long.
The look and feel of this team is different with some notably bold strategic thinking along the way. Which of those choices will work out for the best and which turns into a failure?
The Mets only signing short term pitchers will work out for the best even if they aren't
The Mets didn’t limit themselves to only offering short deals. The Yoshinobu Yamamoto pursuit would’ve changed the narrative of this team if they were successful. By choosing the Los Angeles Dodgers, the Mets were left to stick with the shorter term options available.
Frankly, unless the team wanted to overpay Blake Snell or Jordan Montgomery, there really weren’t all that many great options in free agency. They’ve hesitated to trade away prospects and they probably wouldn’t have had the minor league pitching to acquire any noteworthy arms anyway.
There should be lingering doubts about exactly how good the starting staff can be despite some impressive performances this spring. The absence of Kodai Senga doesn’t help matters, but armed to the tooth with a variety of options, this is a ball club that can survive injuries.
The Mets have allowed themselves as much flexibility as possible in this regard. Something as extreme as DFA’ing a player like Luis Severino if things don’t work out is possible because of the limited financial cost. Available escape pods with all of these pitcher additions will work out whether the Mets are good or not.
The Mets will find a way for the DH spot to not be their Achilles heel
Up for debate, the plan at DH is imperfect and yet not something we have to worry about much for the simple fact it’s the one with the easiest solution. All the Mets have to do is plug in the best hitting player they have who doesn’t have a place to play on the field.
Geared up to hand the DH role primarily to Mark Vientos, it might not begin looking so great but can evolve into a strength rather easily. All it will take is one of the prospects to start hitting well enough to the point where he needs to be in the majors. For example, Drew Gilbert in the majors can push Starling Marte to the DH spot more regularly.
A competitive Mets team has an abundance of directions they could go toward at the trade deadline, too. As long as they avoid repeating the same mistakes from the past by adding players with too strong of limitations like they did in 2022, they should be fine.
Vientos will get a lot of leeway to prove he is or isn’t the man for regular DH at-bats. It’s necessary. The Mets have delayed finding out what he has to offer them for too long. If it doesn’t go the way they want it to, they can bail and look elsewhere.
The far bigger issue than getting production from the DH spot will be solving third base. Vientos is a butcher. Brett Baty isn’t much better and his bat speaks in whispers.
The outfield realignment focusing on defense will crash the offense
Harrison Bader will be a lot of fun to watch with a glove. At the plate, it feels like he’s going to be absent from school a few too many days.
The Mets had two directions they could go this winter with the outfield. The hole in left field will be filled by Brandon Nimmo. Bader will man center field after a bad season offensively and a career where he hasn’t been able to stay very healthy at all. An undoubtedly better defensive alignment can only carry the Mets so far. For every run Bader saves, how many rallies will he kill at the plate?
The Mets did need some sort of an outfield boost. Ideally, one of the large number of left fielders who could have also supplemented the DH spot. Bader is almost redundant on the roster with the presence of Tyrone Taylor. As an everyday player who struggles against right-handed pitchers, Bader could end up as the worst addition of the offseason. It came with a large $10.5 million deal, too.
Perhaps it’s the fact the Mets were tight-budgeted with the offense yet gave Bader this much money which has me feeling like it’ll be a failure most. While Vientos does need regular at-bats at the DH spot, there’s no reason the Mets shouldn’t have already had a suitable backup plan. Did they even talk to Teoscar Hernandez
Bader is a great fourth outfielder who should start regularly against lefties. In the everyday lineup, it seems ridiculous. It’s a lot of money for a ball club with some doubts at third base and DH, a pair of positions where you do want some big offensive numbers.