5 truths about the Mets the fans don’t want to hear

Can you handle the truth? New York Mets fans have had to face some tough ones this year. What should have been a club locked into a postseason race right now is playing out the final games of the 2023 season hoping to, at best, spoil a few evenings for fans in other cities.

Optimism hasn’t completely sunk as the Mets at least did something at the trade deadline to redirect themselves. A good roster is still in place. We couldn’t ask for a better owner.

Still, some truths are hard to accept. None of us want to hear it. If you select false for any of these claims, you’re a hopeful romantic.

1) The NY Mets will have a softer offseason than we want

The offseason is a time when Mets fans can now dream big. Under the watchful wallet of Steve Cohen, anything seems possible. Signing Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander in consecutive offseasons to record-breaking AAVs confirmed this club will “go there.” What’s more, the 2023 roster set a new payroll record itself. Nothing is off limits.

Cohen has already said himself that this winter will be a little different. Following the incident of Scherzer spilling the beans on the club’s plans, the truth of the Mets being far less active heading into 2024 came to light. They should be active to a degree. It’ll be more Sweatin’ to the Oldies than Muscle Beach in the 1970s.

A lackluster offseason will pull air out of the fans. Each time a desired free agent lands somewhere else or an underwhelming one comes to New York, we’re going to feel it. How prepared are you to accept the truth that the Mets might let you down in December?

2) Many of the NY Mets prospects we’re thrilled about won’t make it

We can even lump in the current young players in the major leagues. None of the Baby Mets have secured themselves as future stars. We want to believe Francisco Alvarez’s home run barrage is the beginning of something great. All of the signs are there. He’s one of the few players who has actually made it to the majors and shown off those abilities scouts have raved about.

The same cannot be said for some of his teammates and more so for the guys still in the minors. Will Drew Gilbert or Ryan Clifford become starting outfielders for the New York Mets or find themselves stuck with the Syracuse Mets?

Luisangel Acuna is another prized possession added to the farm. He has big shoes to fill as the brother of a top MVP candidate this year. While we’re not quite expecting him to be Ronald, there is a lot to get excited about for this kid.

Unfortunately, for them and everyone else we have penciled onto the 2027 Mets roster, it’s not going to work. Prospects will suffer injuries. They’ll lack the fortitude to persevere. They may just not know how to hit against major leaguers.

An organization stacked on the farm is fun to have yet it becomes pretty meaningless if they fail to reach their potential. Mets fans do realize this. The harshest part of this truth is more will falter than we’d like to admit.

3) David Stearns won’t single-handedly save the NY Mets franchise

On the field is where the battles take place. Before swords are swung, generals in the front office play the Art of War and decide which soldiers they go to Waterloo with. The hiring of David Stearns already has Mets fans giddy for what’s to come. Can he stabilize the S.S. Mets?

One front office guru cannot save a franchise. We’ve romanticized people like Billy Beane and Theo Epstein. Those “outside of the box” sort of thinkers who do it their way intrigue us to the point where we’ll always welcome anybody different into the picture. Stearns has, thus far, been much more like a young Beane than an Epstein at least in terms of what he has been able to accomplish. Could coming to New York give us some insight into what it would’ve been like if Beane bounced from Oakland and went to Boston? We’ll find out.

It’s going to take much more than a President of Baseball Operations to help the Mets win a championship. After seeing talented players come to the Mets and not get the job done, a guy who isn’t throwing a ball or swinging a bat is already at a disadvantage.

Stearns will no doubt bring a different perspective of the game back to Queens. Will it be enough?

4) The NY Mets are further behind than the Phillies than we ever imagined

The Mets are clearly in a different class than the Atlanta Braves. What about the Philadelphia Phillies? It’s easy to rip on them. They’re more beer league than major league at times. Where the Braves thrive at building young talent and finding good free agents, the Phillies seem to stumble into some success; at least this is the perception they’ve had.

The Phillies are actually much more than this. Far from perfect, they do have a solid starting rotation and a bullpen of far more competent relievers than the Mets had at any point this year. It’s the starting lineup where we can be the most envious. Their mix of power hitting veterans and younger players with pop and the ability to get on base is something the team in Queens hasn’t had for a while.

Mets fans aren’t fearing the Phillies because they’re a beatable team. Their best attribute is what happens when they get hot. They can defeat you with their bats or their arms. Unlike last year’s team when they seemed to be assembled to win via home runs and maybe outpitch you with Aaron Nola or Zack Wheeler, they’re much more balanced. They added the speed of Trea Turner. Bryson Stott can become the next Chase Utley if we give it time.

Compared to the Mets, the Phillies are far superior. It’s not really even all that close. Even in the areas where the Mets may be better, the Phillies aren’t far behind.