Bleacher Report’s Tim Kelly came up with 5 unpopular MLB trades and the New York Mets were included in what doesn’t feel so unpopular of a choice. Not getting too specific about it, he has the Athletics trading star catcher Shea Langeliers to Queens.
A former Atlanta Braves prospect previously used in their trade for Matt Olson, Langeliers has become one of the best hitting catchers in the game. He hit for power but not much else early on. Over the last two seasons, Langeliers is a .270/.326/.507 hitter who has dropped his K% drastically from the high 20s to as low as 19.7% in 2025.
There’s a lot to like about Langeliers, but the Athletics need help elsewhere and might want to capitalize on his trade value at the moment which should be sky high. If the Mets did pursue him, what would the cost be?
This might be what a Mets trade package for Shea Langeliers would look like
As Kelly notes, Francisco Alvarez is practically a given in the trade. No argument here. The Athletics are known to want pitching and that’s where the focus goes: MLB-ready arms.
Mets Receive: Shea Langeliers
Athletics Receive: Francisco Alvarez, Zac Thornton OR Jonah Tong, Zach Franklin
We can’t completely devalue what Alvarez brings on the trade market. He has team control through the 2029 season and one could say he has yet to even reach his full potential. For the same reasons it’s risky for the Mets to keep him, it’s one for the Athletics to swap a proven hitter like Langeliers for the upside of Alvarez.
That’s why they do need more. We give them Zac Thornton or Jonah Tong.
Thornton rose up through the Mets ranks last year and as great as it was, many of his expected statistics were more so-so. He doesn’t strike out a lot of batters nor does any skill at the major league stand out other than an ability to avoid walks. Thornton doesn’t have a role locked in for the 2027 season. If the Mets are determined to add two starting pitchers this offseason, it’s hard to see where he belongs other than minor league depth.
If Thornton doesn’t move the needle for the Athletics, what about Tong? He was always the bigger prospect and yet his stance within the Mets organization seems to have stalled. The club has yet to show any signs of trying to turn him into a reliever. That’s probably premature, but they also don’t have any immediate use for him as a starting pitcher. It seems like 2027 is yet another year of Tong learning on the job while maybe taking a leap forward.
Alvarez and a pitcher with some major league experience (Thornton or Tong) should have the Athletics interested. In addition, the Mets trade them Zach Franklin from the Huascar Brazoban deal. He’s Rule 5 eligible so trading him helps out New York. The Athletics would need to protect him. He’d be a nice arm to try to fit into the bullpen plans for this coming year for either club.
The idea of trading for Langeliers is a bit romantic because it accelerates what we hope Alvarez can become. He adds a more guaranteed thump in the lineup. For the price of some pitching, maybe even Thornton and Tong, the A’s might have to agree. Still not enough? The Athletics are welcome to making Ronny Mauricio or Mark Vientos work or an additional prospect outside of the top 20. Requesting more than that and the Athletics need to pony up something else. The Athletics don't get off easy for trading a guy named Shea to the Mets.
