Brett Baty looks like he can be a NY Mets solution for two needs

Brett Baty hasn't exactly established himself as a New York Mets cornerstone. In the offseason, it was unclear as to whether he'd be traded to an interested suitor along with Mark Vientos and once the year had gotten underway, he seemed like a holdover until something better came along.

He's since turned things around to have a decent season, posting a 94 wRC+ with 1.2 fWAR, making him the eighth most valuable member on the team by the metric. He has played six different positions this year, spending the most time at third base while also making appearances across the infield and in the outfield corners. He's no All-Star but looking ahead, his recent success could line him up to hold two very specific responsibilities next year.

Brett Baty could excel as a platoon option at second base while pinch-hitting against right-handed pitching

Marcus Semien's first season in Queens has been immensely disappointing. Across 536 plate appearances, he has managed a mere 75 wRC+ and -0.4 fWAR. He has a few more years remaining on his contract and isn't too far removed from being one of the better second basemen in baseball so it's reasonable to assume that he'll be around next year, albeit in a diminished role. Why not use Baty to supplement his weaknesses?

While Semien managed an OPS of just .612 against right-handed pitching, Baty posted a .732 OPS. Conversely, Semien's .660 OPS against southpaws is far better than Baty's .506, opening the door to a potential platoon situation at second base. It may seem odd to platoon a player who's set to be owed $26 million in 2027 yet it may be the only way to salvage his underwhelming tenure with the team thus far.

In addition to being respectable at hitting against left-handed pitching, Baty has found plenty of success as a pinch hitter through his career. He has an OPS of .885 across 41 career pinch-hit plate appearances and a 1.643 OPS across 13 pinch-hit plate appearances this season, including two doubles, two home runs, and seven RBI.

The Mets have been optimistic about Baty's value since he debuted and have continued to look for ways to get him playing time. Part of this is a natural consequence of his ability to play multiple roles but there's a real ballplayer somewhere in there. Fans finally got a glimpse of the upside in 2025 when he posted a 3.0 rWAR season and they've been waiting for that to be established as the new norm.

In baseball, the downside of being able to play so many different positions is that you often end up not having a clearly defined niche on the team. Baty has done whatever the team has asked but it hasn't given him an opportunity to get settled. He'll get another year to prove his worth and this situation could be his best chance at cementing his place on this roster. Otherwise it may mean another year of drifting through purgatory on this Mets team.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow