Skip to main content

3 musts in any NY Mets-SF Giants trade for Logan Webb

It's a unique opportunity for both clubs.
ByTim Boyle
Sep 1, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA;  San Francisco Giants starting pitcher Logan Webb (62) delivers a pitch against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the first inning at PNC Park.  Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images
Sep 1, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; San Francisco Giants starting pitcher Logan Webb (62) delivers a pitch against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the first inning at PNC Park. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

FanSided’s Robert Murray dropped the MLB rumors nugget about the San Francisco Giants being open to a deal to move Logan Webb. The star pitcher who has flirted with the Cy Young in several recent seasons is coming off of a down year with the Giants and yet he still has New York Mets fans dreaming of what might be.

A ground ball pitcher with a tendency to eat innings and throw strikes, Webb would be a major get for the Mets if they were able to acquire him this offseason.

There doesn’t seem to be any imminent desire to move him. The Giants are simply listening even if they won’t publicly admit it. Any deal between the Mets and Giants has a few requirements from both sides.

Any Mets-Giants trade involving Logan Webb has these musts

The Mets will need to take on some bad salary

The Giants aren’t going to hand over Webb to the Mets without New York taking on one of their bad contracts as well. The Mets simply don’t have enough to give without being ridiculous that will make them budge. Jefferson Rojas might excite us, but he should hardly motivate the Giants as the lead prospect the same way other teams’ top guys could. The benefit of doing business with the Mets is their consistent spending. Including Rafael Devers, Willy Adames, or Matt Chapman feels necessary. Pick your poison.

The Mets will need to be able to dump some of their own bad money onto the Giants

The Mets wouldn’t just take on the bad contract. They’d need to, at least for a year, subtract some of their own bad money. The worse the contract the Giants get rid of, the longer the deal the Mets will ideally want to move. Marcus Semien out would be the most rewarding considering he is the highest paid of the bad deals and it extends beyond 2027. He’s not nearly as useful in a more limited role whereas Jorge Polanco has the injury excuse (and probably another injury on the way) and Sean Manaea remains at least capable of eating innings for another season. Webb and a bad Giants contract for Semien is a nice start.

Francisco Alvarez will need to be included

The Giants will want a top prospect in the deal. It doesn’t have to be Rojas. They should also seek some immediate major league help. Players like Zac Thornton and Jonah Tong with their minimal MLB experience can qualify to fill that. Francisco Alvarez is in a different class. He’s the former top prospect who has yet to have sustained success in the majors, but has so few candles on his birthday cake and a strong enough bat thus far to continue to intrigue. The Giants have plenty of room to try to nurture Alvarez and maybe pass down some different guidance. If Buster Posey can’t whisper into his ear and fix issues, no one can.

Webb and a bad Giants contract for Semien, Alvarez, and a prospect/young player is the starting point of a deal. It’s player and money motivated. It’s the kind of trade both teams should think about because there aren’t too many other clubs who align this well to provide two solutions.

Add us as a preferred source on Google