The New York Mets had until 6pm to finalize their 40-man roster to protect prospects who’ll be eligible for a Rule 5 Draft either next month or more likely early next year. The unknown of the draft even happening made it a precarious situation with the Mets choosing to protect only Jefferson Rojas.
A lot of other prospects were left off of the 40-man roster. Up for grabs if/when the draft ever takes place, we have to wonder if guys like Jack Wenninger, Gary Gill Hill, or anyone else intriguing end up traded so they aren’t potentially lost for nothing.
More questionable than the actions surrounding the 40-man roster was the choice to DFA Dylan Ross and sign Chayce McDermott to a major league contract. Not long ago, Ross was considered a top Mets relief prospect who just needed to find his control. Today, he’s yesterday’s news and available for 29 teams to take for free.
We have made the following roster moves. pic.twitter.com/grRIjy6AjC
— New York Mets (@Mets) November 17, 2026
The Mets pushing Dylan Ross aside for Chayce McDermott, others still lingering on the 40-man roster doesn't make enough sense
It hasn’t been officially announced, but we can probably assume McDermott got a split contract. Out of options, it makes zero sense to actually sign him to a major league contract of any kind other than to make it a split deal that might pass him through waivers. Either way, a lifetime 10.18 ERA in 20.1 major league innings at 28-years-old hardly suggests he’s a year away from making an impact.
Ross, on the other hand, is only a few months into being 26 and profiles exactly the way the Mets seem to target journeymen free agents. He has struck out batters at a rate of 12.2 K/9 with the issue of walking far too many. He had a 6.34 ERA this past season but managed to pitch to a 1.69 ERA in 32 innings at Triple-A the year prior.
McDermott isn’t so different from Ross. He was a top Baltimore Orioles prospect at one point. The Mets acquired him over the summer in the Ben Rortvedt trade with the Los Angeles Dodgers. A 12.6 K/9 rate in the minors with the expected 5.6 BB/9 rate to make teams timid about any permanent major league role, he is 250 innings deep into his career at the Triple-A level with a 4.10 ERA overall.
Tossing Ross aside so quickly puts a lot of pressure on Ryan Lambert. He had a 7.71 ERA in Triple-A with 9.8 BB/9. The Mets are in no danger of losing him and don’t have to act swiftly to do so. He’s not Rule 5 eligible until 2027. By that point, he’ll have either been added to the 40-man roster or become someone who isn’t even worth protecting.
The Mets have several other candidates on the 40-man roster who might've been more worthy of moving on from than Ross. Is there any point in letting Christopher Morel loiter through the non-tender deadline? Pitchers Jack Anderson and Pierson Ohl don't exactly have the proven track record to guarantee them anything more than a few spot relief appearances. That's if they even make it to Opening Day with the organization. There are plenty of reasons why other teams should put in a claim on Ross. They can stash him in the minor leagues and see if what hasn't worked for the Mets can work for them.
Oddly, McDermott seems bound to get DFA'd at some point anyway barring an injury to other Mets relievers. This note only makes the Ross cut more eyebrow raising.
