5 once popular NY Mets players most fans wouldn’t mind trading away

The fans want changes and those could include trading away any of these once popular players.
New York Mets v Washington Nationals
New York Mets v Washington Nationals | G Fiume/GettyImages
1 of 5

Popularity is overrated. Just about everyone outwears their welcome. Stay around long enough and there’s a chance you become the villain. The rules apply in life and in baseball. After the way things ended for the New York Mets, there are plenty of once popular players the fans aren’t so sure about any longer.

1) Kodai Senga

Kodai Senga’s presence is felt even when he’s not playing. It’s not because he’s larger than life. It’s because with him on the roster, you need to plan for a six-man rotation.

This hasn’t necessarily been because of his own demands, but the Mets have yet to shy away from keeping him on a strict system of getting five days of rest. It can be frustrating at times because throughout a full season it means more openers and Triple-A pitchers starting games for the ball club.

We can understand why this might be a pain. For Mets fans, the frustration with Senga is more about his shrinking abilities as a pitcher. He had one of the most amazing starts to the season. His mid-June injury sent the team spiraling.

Through 14 starts, Senga was 7-3 with a 1.39 ERA. It’s almost easy to forget how dominant he was for the Mets early on. His final 8 games resulted in a 0-3 record and 6.56 ERA. He failed to get through the sixth inning in any of the last 8 starts.

We know Senga can be good but after three seasons, he has become completely unpredictable. His first year in 2023 was tremendous. A lost season due to injuries and setbacks in 2024 had us questioning his durability. Then came 2025 when he had the contrasting halves. Logic tells us he can get back to his best again. Don’t tell that to the fan ready to send him packing.