Skip to main content

There’s no easy right-handed pivot for the NY Mets after Yankees swipe Jonathan Loaisiga

There isn't anyone quite like him.
ByTim Boyle
Sep 26, 2026; San Diego, California, USA;  Arizona Diamondbacks relief pitcher Jonathan Loaisiga (43) throws a pitch during the first inning against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park.  Mandatory Credit: David Frerker-Imagn Images
Sep 26, 2026; San Diego, California, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks relief pitcher Jonathan Loaisiga (43) throws a pitch during the first inning against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: David Frerker-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Jonathan Loaisiga wasn’t going to make or break the New York Mets offseason. However, with their need for some right-handed relief help, they will have a tough time finding a comparable player on the free agent market.

Loaisiga throws hard, gets ground balls, and prevents runs. There is very little to dislike about him and while the Mets have plenty of lefty relievers to choose from still out there, Loaisiga was a quietly underrated righty seeking a new contract.

Baseball Savant has a wonderful page where you can sort through free agents by different measurements. Loaisiga was among the best of the available pitchers in multiple areas with no fair enough right-handed comparison. It’ll be a challenge to find anyone similar without making a trade or taking a stab at someone with faults.

Jonathan Loaisiga alternatives aren’t plentiful for the Mets

There is Loaisiga’s teammate, Ryan Thompson, who has some of the same traits. He’d be a buy low option. He’s coming off of a 4.43 ERA season in a career which sits at 3.67. Also heavy on ground balls and with a successful track record prior to this past year, he has a knack for throwing strikes. What he lacks are strikeouts but Loaisiga isn’t exactly doing any sort of family lineage and discovering he’s related to Nolan Ryan.

Paul Blackburn is another option. We’re not going down that road again are we? His sensational season with the Yankees last year proves the Mets were onto something when they traded for him at the 2024 deadline. The problem is he was hurt and ineffective in a Mets uniform. If you’re going to pivot, you don’t make that signing.

Mark Leiter Jr. has a history with the Yankees and in some ways mimics Loaisiga on a much smaller scale. His 4.28 ERA last year with the Athletics is a turn-off while the 2.95 FIP tells a different story. Leiter Jr. isn’t a half-bad bullpen option. He’s hardly the guy you sign after missing out on someone far better.

Yet another Yankees free agent, John Schreiber is someone to consider. He pitched briefly with the Yankees last year after getting claimed off of waivers from the Kansas City Royals. The benefit of him is adding a little more consistency in his career. He might not be Loaisiga level good, but those financial savings can get poured into ensuring Alex Vesia or any other top lefty doesn’t land elsewhere.

The Mets can certainly turn away from players with similar Loaisiga qualities and add a guy such as Bryan Abreu. Trade possibilities as well, this is a free agent miss with some consequences.

Add us as a preferred source on Google