If David Stearns was in the dictionary, his name would be right next to “mistake.” He made a lot of them this past year for the New York Mets. He was able to survive some of them, the Luis Robert Jr. trade not punishing the Mets too hard for instance. Others are bound to continue to hurt them. The Mets are paying Jorge Polanco how much?
This winter, Stearns is bound to enter more contenders for the blooper reel. One he definitely can’t get away with. Another, he can.
David Stearns can’t afford to buy into the same players who lost his trust
Stearns boldly changed the Mets last offseason. However, there were plenty more options he could have subtracted. It was easier said than done with some. Nobody wanted many of those players whose tanked value made them impossible to trade.
Stearns doesn’t nor can he completely clean house. But changes need to be afoot. This means making decisions on Mark Vientos, Sean Manaea, Kodai Senga, and Ronny Mauricio. We need to start lumping Mauricio into this group. He’s out of options, accomplishing very little in the majors, and so far outside of any of the team’s future plans he might not even be with the club by the time we get to the non-tender deadline later this week.
The likeliest changes we should see are new uniforms for Vientos, Mauricio, and Senga. The trouble with Senga and Manaea together is that neither belongs in the big league rotation to start the year. Senga, at around $10 million less, is more easily tradable and the idea of putting him in the bullpen can tempt someone. The Mets can’t be scared about him excelling in any sort of role. He has been given countless changes and other than a small stretch appears too close to cooked.
David Stearns can afford to let Marcus Semien and Brett Baty battle at second base
Second base already feels like a bit of a wash for the Mets in 2027. The public plan is for Marcus Semien and Brett Baty to battle it out for playing time. Expecting Semien to bounce back after years of declining or Baty to suddenly become more than whatever it is he is (not what we thought) is ambitious.
Why can he get away with this? The prospects definitely help. Between Jefferson Rojas, Emilien Pitre, Mitch Voit, and any veteran they may sign to stash in the minors in hopes of becoming another Jose Iglesias, they have backup options. Cutting Semien now likely lessens where the Mets spend elsewhere. It’s after the 2027 season we can expect his New York tenure to end.
Rather than invest further into second base, the Mets need to consider everything. On the table is a trade deadline rental and even a move of Bo Bichette or A.J. Ewing to the position. They’re so covered with quick triggers to potentially pull they’d be wasting money and possibly a roster spot to sign someone else to man the position.
It’s a mistake to think Semien and Baty are good enough. It’s also one we need to let play out.
