Pete Alonso's NY Mets future is uncertain, but plan for top prospects was made clear

After a season that ended in frustration and fell short of expectations, the New York Mets enter the offseason with plenty of questions and few certainties. High hopes gave way to missed opportunities, and key decisions loom over the front office. Among them is the uncertain future of Pete Alonso, whose stellar season only adds complexity to the roster decisions the team now faces.

At today’s press conference, David Stearns reflected on the campaign and what comes next. His remarks bridged the lingering questions from the previous season to the complexities ahead. He faced questions about the team’s path forward, the balance between immediate competitiveness and emerging talent, and how the organization plans to navigate these challenges. The discussion underscored the high stakes of the offseason and set the stage for the moves that could define the Mets’ future.

David Stearns addresses the Mets offseason and how prospects factor into roster plans

Alonso’s future with the New York Mets remains uncertain following an impressive 2025 season, a topic closely tied to the club's broader plans for the offseason. At today’s press conference, David Stearns acknowledged Alonso’s standout performance and called him a great Met. He also said he would like Alonso back, reflecting the first baseman’s value to the team while leaving his status for the coming offseason open.

Later in the press conference (26:10 mark of press conference), Stearns was asked about the challenge of building a roster while keeping space open for prospects, particularly with the Mets in a win-now position following a disappointing end to the 2025 season. He stated that incorporating young players into the roster is an essential part of winning and winning consistently, and that the organization cannot shy away from that. The exchange highlighted the balancing act the Mets face this offseason.

His remarks carry added significance given the Mets’ highly ranked farm system. With several top prospects, including Jett Williams, Carson Benge, AJ Ewing, and Jacob Reimer, expected to make an impact in the near future, it suggests that the organization may look to the farm to fill some roster holes rather than relying solely on free-agent signings. While Alonso’s situation remains unresolved, the focus on integrating young talent provides insight into how the Mets are approaching roster construction, trying to win next season while giving top prospects opportunities to make an impact.

Stearns’ comments offered a rare window into his philosophy for building the 2026 roster. By stressing the role of young players, he signaled that the Mets see their farm system as more than a pipeline—it’s a key tool in shaping the team’s direction. How those prospects are used could be just as important as any offseason acquisition.