David Peterson's descent from 2025 All-Star to 2026 trade fodder was an apt microcosm of the New York Mets' own failures over the past two years, though the southpaw isn't going to be defined by those struggles in Queens. He rebuilt a lot of his value in Chicago down the stretch, tossing 80⅓ innings of 3.70-ERA ball with the Cubs. I doubt most teams will view him as a mid-rotation option in free agency, but he's clearly a capable back-end starter in the right situation.
That turnaround has reportedly caught the attention of the Colorado Rockies, who are making an all-in push to overhaul their pitching staff right now. They just acquired Luis Castillo and Davis Martin from the Chicago White Sox, meaning that their current rotation lacks any left-handed firepower.
I know that most Mets fans will sneer at the idea of Peterson going to Coors Field after the season he just had. But, insofar as a pitcher can be a "fit" for that ballpark, Peterson might just have what it takes.
David Peterson's failures with Mets have prepared him for adverse conditions elsewhere
Those who have followed Peterson's career closely know that he does one thing better than most: generate groundballs. Over half of the contact he's allowed in each of the past four seasons is on the ground, which is exactly how one would ideally mitigate the high-altitude effects of the Rockies' home.
That's particularly important since the few fly balls that are hit off Peterson are often loud. His home run per fly ball rate has sat above 10% in four of his six big-league seasons, which is the kind of habit that can destroy a pitcher in Colorado. The Cubs tried (and, in a small sample, failed) to help him in this regard, getting him to locate his pitches more effectively down in the zone; perhaps it's no coincide that Peterson's ERA dropped by more than two full runs once his Location+ went from average (100) with the Mets to above average (104) with the Cubs.
Obviously, some really bad luck was baked into that first-half performance in Queens -- his FIP was actually better before the trade that sent him to Chicago. Still, it's no secret as to why the Rockies would have interest in a veteran southpaw who can keep the ball on the ground and off the barrels of opposing hitters' bats.
It'd certainly be a cruel fate to see Peterson thrive in Coors Field after watching him tank in New York. But those struggles with the Mets have only seemed to motivate him, making him a genuinely coveted starting pitcher once again.
