3) Drew Pomeranz
How is this guy still around? He must have some fight in him. Drew Pomeranz debuted in 2011 and through some major injuries, made his way back to MLB in 2025 with the Chicago Cubs. His last MLB appearance was in 2021 with the San Diego Padres.
The amazing thing about Pomeranz is he has been incredible. A member of the Milwaukee Brewers to finish the 2019 campaign, the 2.39 ERA he posted in 26.1 innings there is the highest of any stint.
Pomeranz was one of the gambles Chicago took in the offseason. Alongside Brad Keller and Matthew Boyd, their pitching staff was full of success stories we could’ve easily seen appear on the Mets roster based on Stearns’ proclivity for players like them. His 49.2 innings resulted in a 2.07 ERA along with 10.3 K/9. If MLB still gives out Comeback Player of the Year awards, he feels like an obvious candidate to receive one.
Why not get him? Pomeranz is a lefty and the Mets are already secure there. Between A.J. Minter and Brooks Raley, their current southpaw duo is expensive and effective. There is always the worry of injury with both of them missing extensive time in the last two seasons. Adding Pomeranz to the mix with his injury history does little to solve this.
The same goes for Brent Suter and Hoby Milner. Nice lefty hurlers for sure, it begins to feel unnecessary to carry three southpaws on your bullpen when none of them have minor league options available to them. There’s a reason why the Mets have already signed Richard Lovelady and Joe Jacquez. If there is a need for a trio of southpaws or someone gets hurt, it’s going to be a lesser pitcher than any of the pricier options such as Pomeranz.
