The New York Mets sought out and signed a unique free agent who, just last week, was reportedly interested in a major league contract. Who isn’t? Darwinzon Hernandez joins the Mets on a 3-year deal worth $12 million.
We profiled him before, noting how he fit the style of free agent David Stearns should seek. Signing him for three years was a bit of a surprise but at the cost of what the Mets paid A.J. Minter per season spread out across three, there’s a lot to appreciate.
Our lack of familiarity with Hernandez shouldn’t have any fan thinking negatively. This deal has high potential even if it comes with a crash and burn warning.
Give the Mets signing of Darwinzon Hernandez an A-
Hernandez has major league experience, 85.1 innings in fact. The 2022 season was the last time he made an appearance with a few more recent years being the time where he mastered a few things overseas in Japan. Wildness was a hallmark of his issues. More of a strike-thrower without sacrificing his high strikeout rate all that much, Hernandez is a key example of the type of player the Mets dream Jefry Yan would become.
FanGraphs lists Hernandez as having one minor league option left. What’s unknown is whether his contract actually contains anything about whether or not he can be demoted. One would think the Mets would be more reluctant to give him three years if that was part of the language. Expect him to have the minor league outage clause which basically means he’s an arbitration-eligible player with a $4 million AAV that won’t enlarge.
The ability to send Hernandez to the minor leagues is a weapon the Mets couldn’t resist. This allows them additional roster flexibility. In fact, they shouldn’t completely remove the idea of planning for a scenario where he spends at least some time in the minor leagues this year. Hernandez joins Nate Lavender as the best lefty bullpen duo on the roster. Those two could conceivably battle it out for a roster spot if the Mets choose to add anyone else to the mix.
Lefty relievers have tended to bring the extremes of success or failure. Brooks Raley wasn’t incredibly well accomplished when he first joined the Mets ahead of the 2023 season and earned his way into becoming a fan-favorite we’d love back. Then there’s Richard Lovelady whose name made him a fun idea but whose performance made him a punchline.
Hernandez’s 1.48 ERA last year in Japan with 11 K/9 and 3.4 BB/9 measured up too well in comparison to what looks to be an expensive free agent class of pitchers. After last year’s flurry of players returning to the major leagues from overseas success, the Mets couldn’t let another year go by without investing in someone. Players like Foster Griffin, Anthony Kay, Drew Anderson, and more didn’t get lost in translation. Whatever skills they picked up came with them back to the US. This hardly guarantees Hernandez will do the same. Luckily for the Mets, the 2027 campaign doesn’t even need to be a major success if we view Hernandez appropriately as expensive depth.
The biggest fear with Hernandez is he morphs back into the wild-thrower he was for much of his professional career in the United States. Even if a high walk rate, as long as it's not extreme, follows him here the Mets can feel the reward of this deal.
