Risky NY Mets center field experiment shouldn't get off the ground

The New York Mets, already navigating the early season with a platoon in center field between Tyrone Taylor and the defensively gifted José Siri, now face a significant void. Siri, acquired for his elite speed and defensive prowess, unfortunately, suffered a fractured left tibia, leaving an indefinite timeline for his return.

This unexpected setback has forced the Mets to explore internal options to cover the crucial center field position. According to a recent post by Tim Healy on X, the Mets are considering an intriguing, albeit risky, experiment during Jeff McNeil’s current rehab assignment: playing him in center field.

Mets' gamble on McNeil in center field could be disastrous

The Mets reportedly view McNeil, a versatile player known for his hitting ability, as a potential stopgap solution to mitigate the impact of Siri’s absence, which could extend for several months. However, this potential move could be a costly miscalculation for the Mets.

General Manager David Stearns emphasized throughout the offseason the organization's commitment to fielding their best defensive lineup. The acquisition of Siri, specifically for his outfield defense and speed, underscored this priority. Shifting McNeil, a player with minimal experience in center field and whose corner outfield defense is considered average directly contradicts this stated philosophy.

McNeil’s skillset doesn't naturally align with the demands of center field. The position requires exceptional quickness, agility, and reaction time – attributes not typically associated with McNeil's game. Furthermore, his arm strength is not a standout feature.

This becomes particularly concerning given the Mets' outfield configuration. With Juan Soto in right field, a player whose range is not his primary strength, and Brandon Nimmo’s ongoing battles with discomfort and injuries in left field, the need for a center fielder with significant range and coverage is paramount. The Mets have been cautious with Nimmo to preserve his health.

Instead of this gamble with McNeil, the Mets have more logical internal alternatives. Jose Azocar could serve as a temporary, occasional option in center field, allowing Tyrone Taylor to assume the everyday role. This arrangement would maintain a more defensively sound outfield.

Additionally, this situation presents an opportunity for top outfield prospect Drew Gilbert to gain more consistent playing time in the minor leagues, allowing him to further develop and potentially prove himself ready for a major league call-up to fill the center field void later this summer.