Skip to main content

NY Mets advisors have an undeniable connection to non-tendered Yankees players

How much does the connection matter?
ByTim Boyle
Apr 21, 2026; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; New York Yankees pitcher Luis Gil (81) is relieved as they take on the Boston Red Sox in the seventh inning at Fenway Park. Mandatory Credit: David Butler II-Imagn Images
Apr 21, 2026; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; New York Yankees pitcher Luis Gil (81) is relieved as they take on the Boston Red Sox in the seventh inning at Fenway Park. Mandatory Credit: David Butler II-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The New York Yankees ended up non-tendering two players on Friday and it’s hard to deny how each could be a match for the New York Mets. Beyond their abilities, each has a direct link to a newly hired Mets advisor.

Fernando Cruz is a former Cincinnati Reds reliever who crossed paths with Derek Johnson. Cruz didn’t debut in the majors until his age 32 campaign. Some health concerns, despite a 3.13 ERA performance this past year, had the Yankees thinking twice about committing around $2.3 million to him as MLB Trade Rumors projected.

Their other non-tendered player, Luis Gil, is a one-time Minnesota Twins prospect who ended up traded to the Yankees for Jake Cave. One of those memorably bad deals for the Twins, it was a trade Derek Falvey has to regret. Years after the trade, Luis Gil won the 2024 AL Rookie of the Year. Cave was a solid bench player for Minnesota and is now bouncing around the minors and international leagues.

The Mets can get at least a little extra input from the two Dereks in the front office

The injury concerns for Cruz put him in a spot where an incentive-laden contract is likely. Diagnosed with a partially torn UCL, it’s no guarantee he misses time but also a ticking time bomb for his career to be all but over. Cruz is already closer to 40 than he is 30. Throwing as hard as he does, turning 37 in March puts him at a huge free agent disadvantage.

The Mets showed us when they traded Huascar Brazoban at last summer’s trade deadline they might be considerate of things like a player’s age. It’s not as if the return of Zach Franklin and Gabe Davis was so irresistible. The Mets haven’t been afraid to sign players with an injury history or even ones already on the IL. A conversation between David Stearns and Johnson can help sway the POBO. However, Cruz’s best days were the last two seasons with the Yankees. Johnson saw a less effective model in Cincinnati.

Gil is equally as intriguing especially for a Mets club that prides itself on starting pitching depth. Gil has spent a good part of the last two seasons hurt or in the minor leagues. Only 28-years-old and no birthday until next June, the trouble the Mets would have is finding an actual spot for him. There is always a place for a reliever like Cruz. Gil isn’t ready to become a reliever and would be more sensible in the starting rotation.

Let’s say the Mets do sign Tarik Skubal. This leaves them with rotation spots occupied by Nolan McLean and Christian Scott for sure. Sean Manaea and Kodai Senga are outliers. Zac Thornton is someone that could get demoted simply because they’ve upgraded elsewhere. But is Gil even an upgrade over Thornton?

The Mets need to subtract more from their pitching staff in order to fit a player like Gil who might just end up as a bullpen long man if starting doesn't work immediately. He fits well into the model of player the Mets have sought in the past, Griffin Canning being one of the more successful outcasts from another team to put together a strong performance.

Falvey’s input here would be limited as nearly a decade has gone by since he traded him from the Twins. The biggest downside with Gil is his presence on the Mets roster suggests less of a sure thing with one rotation spot. The Mets can do better unless he’s willing to take a minor league deal. I’d guess another team would have more of a reason to promise and deliver big league starts.

Cruz feels the far better match on a roll of the dice type of signing. But if the Yankees weren't even interested in him at such a low cost, what could it actually mean for his health? For Gil, it's simply a matter of needing a greater guarantee and poor timing. An out of options pitcher struggling to stay healthy and not performing well last year is not the goal.

Add us as a preferred source on Google