On Tuesday, MLB teams will have to decide which prospects to protect (or not) from the still pending Rule 5 Draft. The Rule 5 Draft is scheduled for December which, by that point, the sport is probably going to be in full lockout mode. Whether or not the league ends up having a Rule 5 Draft or not is anyone’s guess, but teams need to operate as if they will. The New York Mets are a team with some notable big decisions to make and the last few years’ results can hint at what they should do.
Broken down into a few different categories, this is how the Mets should approach the 40-man roster decisions.
Mets prospect decisions for the 40-man roster deadline
The Mets must protect Jefferson Rojas
The only given is Jefferson Rojas. The top prospect in the system and someone who could become a major league factor quickly, there is no debating his status. David Stearns won’t have an easier decision for the remainder of 2026.
The Mets have to think carefully about these other prospects
Chris Suero feels like the kind of guy who could get taken because this versatile catcher can do more than suit up behind the plate. A team could stash him as a third-catcher type capable of playing some first base and the outfield. I’d still have doubts he can last on most major league rosters for the full season. He hit only .201 in Double-A last season. I don’t see the Mets protecting him.
Jack Wenninger is one of those prospects who have fallen slightly. He feels like he could get taken. If Mike Vasil was unable to survive in the 2024 Rule 5 Draft, there’s enough evidence to suggest a team could consider Wenninger as a candidate to be a longman in their bullpen. After Rojas, Wenninger is the next most likely to protect.
Gary Gill Hill shouldn’t be protected just because the Mets recently acquired him in the Freddy Peralta trade. It’s more of his talent that should have them considering him. However, a lack of experience beyond Double-A definitely makes him feel more like a guy who could get returned to the Mets or passed over. This is a tough call. Hill, if taken, might always be someone who simply slides back to the Mets.
These Mets prospects aren’t worth protecting
Ryan Clifford was so bad in Triple-A this past year that adding him to the 40-man roster would be overcomplicating things. He’s not getting taken and if he did then succeeded, good for the team who claimed him.
Randy Guzman is too far from the majors to consider protecting. As promising as his career has been, a 40-man roster spot would eat up one of his minor league options way too quickly.
Jacob Reimer is another one of those power-hitting prospects who can’t seem to put it all together. Rule 5 eligible this winter, he’d need to outperform expectations to hang on anyone’s big league roster. Reimer is probably more of a trade candidate at this point and someone the Mets should try shopping immediately.
Zach Franklin is a halfway decent pitching prospect added from the Huascar Brazoban trade. The problem with not protecting him is the point of trading Brazoban becomes even more questionable. The Mets never gave Franklin a big league shot late in 2026 despite already knowing they would have this decision to make with him. It sends a signal they’re willing to risk it and they probably should.
Anyone not mentioned falls into this category as well. They are too irrelevant at the moment to put on the 40-man roster.
The Mets have several other prospects eligible for the Rule 5 Draft with mostly pitching on the table to get stolen. As for selecting someone, it does feel feasible they can at least flirt with the idea although with the way this roster has been managed, it doesn't feel likely any choice would manage to stick around.
