Jun 25, 2014; New York, NY, USA; New York Mets starting pitcher Zack Wheeler (45) pitches against the Oakland Athletics during the first inning of a game at Citi Field. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

Zack Wheeler is being severely undervalued


For his career, Zack Wheeler has made 35 starts. In those 35 starts, he’s posted a 3.75 ERA, and has struck out 8.17 batters per nine innings.

Compared to 2013, Wheeler’s strikeouts per nine in 2014 are up, his walks per nine are down, his velocity is up, his FIP is down, and his home runs per nine are down.

Additionally, Wheeler – who sometimes suffers when hitters sit on his fastball, has made an important adjustment in 2014. He’s throwing his fastball 63.1 percent of the time, down from 71.1 percent in 2013.

Over his last 10 starts, Wheeler has gone six innings or more on seven occasions, including his first big league shutout.

Still, for some reason, there are those who are down on Wheeler.

There are false narratives that suggest Wheeler might not have the “mentality” for New York (which are based on absolutely nothing), those who compare him to Mike Pelfrey (a comparison that makes no sense), and some who even argue that Wheeler is just now “proving” that he belongs in the majors.

Wheeler is a 24-year-old who has basically one full season in the majors under his belt. He has tremendous stuff, has improved in almost all areas from 2013 to 2014, carries himself well, and appears to be close to harnessing his natural ability. There’s also this:

While many can see how good Wheeler has been, what his potential is, and how much value he has, others are willing to trade him – specifically in a deal for Cubs shortstop Starlin Castro.

On Sunday, John Harper of the Daily News wrote that the Mets should trade Wheeler and perhaps Jacob deGrom in exchange for Castro. This wasn’t an actual rumor, just an idea from Harper based on conversations with an executive who doesn’t work for the Mets or Cubs.

Castro, even with his defensive issues, questions about his maturity, and shockingly bad 2013 campaign, has lots of value and is someone the Mets should consider acquiring. However, there’s no reason for the Mets to consider dealing Wheeler for Castro – nor is there anything to suggest the Mets would ponder such a move.

What the Mets and lots of fans know, is that Zack Wheeler is a very good starting pitcher who has a chance to be one of the best in baseball. He isn’t currently what Matt Harvey was in 2013, nor should he have been expected to be.

The undervaluing and sometimes laughable criticism surrounding Wheeler isn’t surprising, but that doesn’t make it any less off base.

Wheeler remains, with good reason, one of the keys to the future of the Mets – regardless of the faint cries of a hysterical minority.


Next Mets Game View full schedule »
Friday, Aug 2222 Aug7:10at Los Angeles DodgersBuy Tickets

Tags: Starlin Castro Zack Wheeler

  • Dave S

    Again, just LOL funny. Really, you wouldn’t trade a potential 1 or 2 starter for a cost controlled All-Star shortstop who is 24 year old. Quit being delusional. That isn’t “undervalued”. It would take MORE than one young pitcher – no matter how good – to pry away a young everyday player who is an all-star at SS. You’d have to offer Wheeler and another guy who projects as a ML starter. Crap, the Cubs just traded TWO seasoned starters for four prospects – one of whom is elite. And people are saying it was a trade that made sense for everyone. Yet you somehow think an All-Star SS who is 24 and cost controlled through 2019 isn’t worthy of two pitching prospects? Good grief.

    • Leonardo Nascimento

      You’re the one who is delusional. Comparing the Mets situation to the A’s situation is absurd. The A’s overpaid the Cubs by giving their two of their best prospects for Samardzija and Hammel, but teams who want to win NOW usually end up overpaying. The Mets are not even close to contending to even consider overpaying for someone.

      You keep saying that Castro is an All-Star SS, but that doesn’t mean anything. He’s having a good year, but the fact is that he is a below average defender, an average baserunner, doesn’t get on base a lot and hits for only moderate power. I don’t think he would be worth someone like Wheeler or Syndergaard even if we were contending, much less now.