Aug 20, 2013; Oakland, CA, USA; Seattle Mariners second baseman Nick Franklin (20) is unable to turn the ball as Oakland Athletics earn a single during the second inning at Coliseum. Mandatory Credit: Kelley L Cox-USA TODAY Sports

On Nick Franklin: Mets Have To Give To Get

The Mets would like to make an upgrade at shortstop and Seattle’s Nick Franklin is reportedly available via trade. There’s a potential match there, but the Mets will have to part with something of quality in order to make it happen.

Yes, the Mariners have a glut of middle infielders due to the signing of second baseman Robinson Cano and the emergence of young shortstop Brad Miller. No, that doesn’t mean the Mets – or any team – will be able to swoop in and acquire Franklin for a mid-tier prospect or a reliever. That’s not how this works.

Franklin, 22, is viewed by pretty much every scout who’s ever watched him as a plus bat. There are some who worry about his ability to stick at shortstop for the long haul, and some who think he can be just about average there.

If the Mets feel Franklin can handle shortstop, they should strongly consider dealing for him. If they think Franklin will have to switch to second base, he becomes much less appealing.

According to Baseball Prospectus, Franklin profiles as a player who “stands out for his ability to make consistent hard contact and drive the ball to all fields. He has a line-drive swing that will max out with 15-18 home runs a year, but should also generate 30-plus doubles at his peak. Franklin’s swing is simple and compact from the left side, allowing him to work counts and hit for a high average.”

Let’s say for the sake of argument that Mets people believe Franklin will be able to stick at shortstop.

That would make Franklin a 22 year old switch hitting shortstop who has the ability to hit for both average and power. There’s tremendous value in that.

What would the Mets have to give up for him?

According to reports, the Mariners want major league ready starting pitching. Names that immediately come to mind are Rafael Montero, Dillon Gee, and Jacob deGrom.

I’ve seen it written that the Mets absolutely should not deal any of their starting pitching. Matthew Cerrone of MetsBlog stated that he wouldn’t give up Jacob deGrom for Nick Franklin. While I respect Matt’s opinion, I can’t agree with him there.

What seems to be happening, is that Mets fans are severely overvaluing the chips the club has while severely undervaluing Nick Franklin. You have to give to get. A trade for a top prospect will not be consummated by offering a team middling prospects and/or relievers who aren’t established.

Moreover, the notion that the Mets can’t give up any of their starting pitching is a notion I find to be absurd. At present, the Mets have Jonathon Niese, Bartolo Colon, Zack Wheeler, Dillon Gee, Jenrry Mejia, Rafael Montero, Jacob deGrom, Daisuke Matsuzaka, John Lannan, and Noah Syndergaard as pitchers who are able to pitch at the big league level.

The Mets’ starting pitching depth is strong, and it should only improve next year – or late this season – when Matt Harvey returns.

Most trade proposals I’ve seen surmise that the Mets would be able to land Franklin if they dangle Rafael Montero. I’m torn on whether or not I’d pull the trigger, since I feel that most scouts are underselling how good Montero can be at the major league level.

Still, if the Mets continue to find Scott Boras’ demands for Stephen Drew outlandish, their best bet will be to take a long look at Franklin while weighing what it will be worth to acquire him.


Thanks for reading! Be sure to follow @RisingAppleBlog on Twitter and Instagram, and Like Rising Apple’s Facebook page to keep up with the latest news, rumors, and opinion.

Next Mets Game View full schedule »
Friday, Aug 2222 Aug7:10at Los Angeles DodgersBuy Tickets

Tags: New York Mets Nick Franklin

  • Pete Anselmo

    Although I love Dillon Gee to death, I feel like a Gee for Franklin swap could get it done. A proven major leaguer for an unproven youngster with a higher ceiling sounds fair to me. That would also allow the Mets to give Montero a shot at the rotation sooner rather than later.

  • Victor Chu

    I’d give up deGrom but not Gee or Montero for Franklin right now … the .225 BA worries me, especially in Citi Field. Franklin sounds like a younger Stephen Drew less the defensive skills.
    By mid-summer, I’d might be willing to give up Gee, if Meija is the real deal this year and both Montero and Syndergaard live up to expectations in AAA or with the Mets … by then, we will know what we have in Tejada, assuming we don’t get Drew or anyone else to replace/platoon with him.

  • Bill

    As an advocate of trading for a young shortstop rather than a obtaining a short term fix through free agency, this is a discussion I have been waiting for. If Seattle would do a Franklin for Montero or Gee even up trade today, and I’m the Mets, I’d do that one in a heartbeat. I suspect that Seattle, like Alderson all winter will play some hardball and try to get a little sweeter pot – maybe Montero and a lower level prospect (or non-prospect). I’d also keep an eye on the Arizona situation and see if the same deal might be on the table for one of their two guys. Not sure who I would rather have – probably Gregorius.

  • nhjim1

    GET DREW!!!!!! GET DREW!!!!!! GET DREW!!!!!!!,,,,,,,,,,AARGH!!!!!!!!