Sep 28, 2013; New York, NY, USA; New York Mets relief pitcher Vic Black (38) throws a pitch against the Milwaukee Brewers during the eighth inning at Citi Field. Mandatory Credit- Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

Is The Mets Bullpen Actually In Bad Shape?

While the Mets continue to ponder whether or not they’ll upgrade shortstop before the 2014 season begins, there’s a growing sentiment that the bullpen situation may be worse than the shortstop one.

Is the concern about the bullpen based in reality, or is it simply residual worrying from a fanbase that’s still wary despite the fact that the Mets have finally jumped back into the free agent market with both feet and appear headed in the right direction?

At present, it appears that the Mets have nine relievers for seven spots.

If the season started today, the bullpen would likely consist of Bobby Parnell, Vic Black, Jeurys Familia, Josh Edgin, Scott Rice, Carlos Torres, and one of Gonzalez Germen, Joel Carreno, or Jeff Walters.  Every one of those pitchers is on the 40-man roster except Carreno, who the Mets signed to a minor league deal in November.

As Rising Apple’s Dan Haefeli pointed out earlier today on Twitter, Parnell, Black, Familia, Edgin, Rice, and Germen combined to put up a 3.31 FIP (fielding independent pitching) in 2013.  Haefeli noted that there are depth concerns, but the pitchers the Mets have in place are certainly capable.

In addition to the six pitchers above, the Mets have Walters, who was stellar as the closer for Double-A Binghamton last season, Torres, who will likely be used in a swingman capacity, and Carreno, who many observers view as someone who can be a solid piece.  The 27 year old Carreno, who had a cup of coffee in the majors with Toronto in 2012, struck out 10.53 per 9 last year while with Toronto’s Triple-A affiliate.

Of the nine relievers who are competing for the seven spots in the Mets’ pen, seven are between 24 and 29 years old.  The elder statesmen are lefty specialist Rice (32 years old), and Torres (31 years old).

Among those relievers are three who can touch close to 100 MPH on the radar gun (Parnell, Black, and Familia), two capable lefties (Edgin and Rice), one solid piece who can pitch middle or late innings or spot start (Torres), and three other guys who are lacking in experience but have live arms (Germen, Carreno, and Walters).

Is it risky to roll with a bullpen like the one the Mets may roll with?  Yes.  At the same time, the group the Mets have assembled has the potential to be very good.

As anyone who follows baseball knows, bullpen arms (with very few exceptions) are extremely volatile year to year.  Signing relievers who are viewed as established contributors guarantees nothing.  For recent examples, take a look at Frank Francisco, Jon Rauch, and Brandon Lyon.

The relievers the Mets have assembled aren’t a sure thing, but neither is any other collective bullpen.  For a team like the Mets, whose strength is its starting pitching, I’ll gladly take the chance that the relievers currently on board can form a solid pen – especially when the alternative is throwing millions at “established” relievers whose presence would guarantee nothing except for long leashes in the event that they struggle.


Thanks for reading! Be sure to follow @RisingAppleBlog on Twitter and Instagram, and Like Rising Apple’s Facebook page to keep up with the latest news, rumors, and opinion.

Tags: Bobby Parnell New York Mets Vic Black

  • Pingback: Fishing the NL East: Atlanta Braves Early Favorites? - Marlin Maniac - A Miami Marlins Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and More

  • AceRuby

    They just need to sign a veteran arm like Mitchell Boggs to fill out the bullpen really other then that I think they are in good shape their.

  • Herb G

    The Mets have a ton of bull pen talent in the organization. In addition to the 9 mentioned in the article, you forgot to mention the newest candidate, Ryan Reid, who definitely has a shot. Additionally, there’s Gorski, Leathersich and Kolarek who are on the doorstep. Notwithstanding that, I think Alderson wants to acquire one veteran arm to provide stability to a young staff. Boggs would be a good signing. If Parnell is ready to go in spring training, we go into the season with him, Black, Torres. Edgin, Rice, new guy, and the last spot is up for grabs. Germen, Familia, Carreno, Reid, and Walters, are the top candidates for tthat last spot, or 2 spots if Parnell issn’t ready yet.

  • chums41

    They don’t need to sign any veteran arms, period!!! As Danny noted, veteran arms guarantee us nothing except a reduction in payroll that would be better invested in savings account paying 0.005% interest. In the list of “piles of crap we have signed” over the past several years, you left out J.J. Putz. Putz took $6mm from us while providing us with the following $150k stats: Win/Loss; 1-4; ERA,, 5.22, innings pitched; a whopping 29,1 before going down with a season ending injury in June of 2009. Let’s go with the young kids, like Atlanta has done and see how it shakes out in 2014. While it would be great to make the playoffs next year, the percentages are against us so we might as well determine which young pitchers will be part of our future.