May 8, 2013; Chicago, IL, USA; St. Louis Cardinals second baseman Matt Carpenter (13) hits a triple against the Chicago Cubs during the seventh inning at Wrigley Field. Mandatory Credit: Rob Grabowski-USA TODAY Sports

Daniel Murphy: All-Star?

One of the few bright spots for the Mets in this not-so-merry month of May has been the reemergence of Daniel Murphy as a force at the plate. Since seeing his average drop to .258 on May 12, Murph has hit at a .432 clip with a 1.139 OPS in his last 11 games, picking up six doubles, two home runs, and seven RBIs even as his team went 3-8.

May 22, 2013; New York, NY, USA; New York Mets second baseman Daniel Murphy (28) hits a sacrifice fly against the Cincinnati Reds during the fifth inning of a game at Citi Field. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

As part of the desperate search for good news that has become a daily routine for Mets fans, the question should be asked if Daniel Murphy will get a spot on the National League All-Star team. David Wright and Matt Harvey are almost certainly locks for a Midsummer Classic appearance, and with Major League Baseball maybe looking to put as many home players as they can in the game, Murphy calling Citi Field his baseball home may be enough to tip the scales in his favor. But will he get the nod? And more importantly, would he deserve it?

At first glance I’ve been tempted to, and often have, exclaimed, “Why, of course!” With his numbers as rock-solid as they are and skills with a glove up to major-league standards, why shouldn’t he get to shine in the limelight of playing at home in his first All-Star Game? Indeed, Murphy does have a good slate of statistics: his .302 batting average is second amongst all NL second basemen, his 14 doubles are fourth in the entire league, and he has turned an NL-best 30 double plays.

But Murphy is far from the only second baseman with the numbers to earn him one of baseball’s Golden Tickets. While Daniel’s second half of May has been superhuman, Marco Scutaro of the Giants has been superhuman the whole month. In 18 May games, Scutaro is hitting .453 with a 1.119 OPS, 14 runs, five doubles, two triples, a home run, and 7 RBIs. His resulting .331 season average puts him miles ahead of every other NL second baseman, Murphy included.

Meanwhile, a handful of other middle (infield)-men who bubble under Murph in batting average do overtake him in other highly-regarded stats. The biggest threat comes from Matt Carpenter of St. Louis, who is hitting .300 and leads N.L. second basemen in doubles (15), OPS (.828), and WAR (2.0). Murphy ranks only fifth in OPS (.798) and fourth in WAR (1.3); his biggest shortfall in the former category is a lack of walks – he’s drawn only eight bases on balls all season, second to last for regulars at his position, putting him at a too-low .333 OBP.  That drags down his very good SLG (.465 to Carpenter’s .441) when combined into OPS.

Carpenter is just in the lead of a pack that’s nipping at the heels of our protagonist. Cincinnati’s Brandon Phillips boasts a position-leading 40 RBI’s, nearly double Murphy’s total of 21. Jedd Gyorko is quietly giving the Padres a good effort and has an .801 OPS to show for it. And as always, lurking in the shadows is Chase Utley of the Phillies, older but still effective with seven home runs and a position-leading .475 SLG. Phillips and Utley also have the name recognition that is so crucial in fan voting, and there is nothing residents of Philadelphia would take delight in more (except maybe a decent Eagles team) than seeing their guy starting at second base in an All-Star Game hosted by their hated New York rivals.

So let’s answer both questions. First, does Daniel Murphy deserve to be an All-Star? He’s borderline, strong in a lot of categories but not the best in any of them, and that constitutes an emphatic “maybe” (as emphatic as that word can sound). Second, will Daniel Murphy make the All-Star team? With Scutaro, Phillips, and Utley as competition, probably not on the fan vote. It would take selection by the National League manager, San Francisco’s Bruce Bochy, for that dream to be realized.

Keeping up his hot streak would go a long way towards earning that selection, and that’s all Murph can really do at this point. With his team in the toilet, Daniel Murphy’s daily mission is to give it his all and produce as many small victories as he can. Maybe those small victories will eventually start showing up again in the win column of the New York Mets.


Thanks for reading! Be sure to Like Rising Apple’s Facebook page and follow @RisingAppleBlog on Twitter to keep up with the latest news, rumors, and opinion.

Next Mets Game View full schedule »
Tuesday, Sep 22 Sep7:10at Miami MarlinsBuy Tickets

Tags: All-Star Daniel Murphy Marco Scutaro Matt Carpenter New York Mets

  • Old_Backstop

    As much as I root for the Murph, I would have to say no. His glove is not up to par with some of the other guys mentioned. His lack of walks and speed make him a non-ideal table-setter, and his lack of HR power makes him a non-ideal RBI man. He’s done a good job of bettering himself defensively, and deserves credit. He’s no longer the sore thumb that sticks out at the position, but I would call him a serviceable 2B, not an all-star. Not this year, anyway.

    • MD92468

      At first I balked at the idea, but he’s not as far off as you might think. Still, there’s a chasm between him (or most other 2Bs) and Phillips…and with Utley returning to form, it’s hard to imagine someone picking Murphy over him if their stats are comparable. There won’t be more than two 2B on the roster…too many good players at other positions…

    • Old_Backstop

      I agree, he’s not that far off. I was just saying, I can think of 4-5 guys I would prefer over him. Gyorko gets a tough rap having to play half of his games in Petco. Utley is coming back from injury, but I would still take him over Murphy – he has the ability to drill 20 homeruns without much trouble. Marco Scutaro I would NOT take over Murphy for the long haul due to age, but he’s having a better season thus far. And then you have Carpenter and Phillips, who are better.

      The rest of the NL starters (Rutledge, Uggla, Espinoza, Prado, Weeks), in my opinion are much lesser 2B’s than Murphy.

  • metsfaninparadise

    I think the conclusion to be drawn from your summary of the statistics is that he’s in the discussion, which couldn’t have been said last year. However, I think the premise that MLB is trying to squeeze an excess of home-team players onto the roster is unsupported. Harvey, Wright and Parnell seem like locks, and 3 would probably be “enough.” Anyone additional is going to have to earn it.

  • Pingback: Morning Briefing: Braves the model? | All New York Mets