June 13, 2012; St. Petersburg, FL, USA; New York Mets second baseman Daniel Murphy (28) hits a single in the seventh inning against the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field. New York Mets defeated the Tampa Bay Rays 9-1.Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement-US PRESSWIRE

What's With Daniel Murphy's Slump?


After hitting .301 through April and May this season, Daniel Murphy has dropped off once the calendar hit June. This month, he’s boasting a triple slash of .188/.188/.261…not something worth writing home about. To make matters worse, Murphy hasn’t been running the base paths very well and leads all second basemen in errors this season. This slump, coupled with his season long power outage (0 HR in 262 ABs) have gotten people talking about Jordany Valdespin, who has shown more pop than Murphy in half the at-bats this season. Though Valdespin may be the 2nd baseman of the future in some people’s eyes (not mine), there is an easy fix to Murphy’s slump that includes some slight adjustments.

While Murph has never been known as a home run hitter, one can normally expect between 10-15 longballs in any given season, so not having any as we get close to July can be concerning. What’s more concerning to me is that Murphy isn’t hitting the ball in the air as much as he was last year, when he produced at a .320/.362/.448 clip in 462 at-bats. His GB/FB

ratio is 2.42, almost 1.00 higher than last year’s ratio (1.52). Although he’s hitting line drives at the same rate (21% in ’12 vs. 21.9% in ’11), the previous statistic shows that he’s hitting more groundballs than ever. He’s hitting balls on the ground at a 55.9% rate this year, up nearly 9% from last year, and is hitting the ball in the air 23.1% of the time, an 8% decrease from the season prior.

It is understandable that a hitter doesn’t want to hit the ball in the air too often because it will be easier for defensive players to make a play, but Murphy is a doubles hitter, so getting the ball in the air, whether it’s a line drive or fly ball, is incredibly important. So, why is this happening? Like almost any slump, Murph has looked off-balance at the plate, rolling over pitches a lot and almost playing pepper with the second baseman on a nightly basis. This is happening because pitchers are not throwing him as many fastballs as last year, and he hasn’t been able to adjust to it yet.

Since he broke onto the scene with New York in 2008, he’s seen a fastball at the plate about 62% of the time. So far this season, pitchers have only been throwing a fastball to Murphy about 57% of the time. From last year to this year, he’s seen more sliders (+1.7%), cutters (+1.3%), curveballs (+0.9%), and changeups (+1.3%) than ever before. That doesn’t sound like a huge difference, but with baseball being a game of inches, it means a lot. It now makes sense that Murphy is playing pepper with the second baseman, because he’s out in front of all the off-speed pitches that are getting thrown at him, and rolling them over on the ground to the right side of the infield.

A simple adjustment needs to be made for him break out of this month-long slump and get back to the productive hitter we know he is. Murphy has always been able to adjust to what pitchers have been doing to him, it’s just taking him a little longer to do so. Will he be our second baseman for years to come? That’s not very likely. However, all this talk about trading Murphy or sitting him in favor of Valdespin is nonsenese. After how we saw Terry Collins stood by Ike Davis, there is no way the Mets are going to give up on Daniel Murphy this quickly. He hit a couple balls hard last night, so let’s see if he can build on that tonight against Brian Matusz.

Next Mets Game View full schedule »
Friday, Aug 2929 Aug7:10Philadelphia PhilliesBuy Tickets

Tags: Brian Matusz Daniel Murphy Daniel Murphy Slump FanSided Ike Davis Jordany Valdespin Matt Musico New York Mets Rising Apple Second Basemen Terry Collins

  • MikeyJoe

    “Though Valdespin may be the 2nd baseman of the future in some people’s eyes (not mine)…”
    “All this talk about trading Murphy or sitting him in favor of Valdespin is nonsenese…”
     
    Matt – this is a terrific assessment; it is both balanced and insightful. I love the quotes above…spot on!!
     
    As I read your piece, I said to myself FINALLY someone who’s focusing on what Murph can (and has) offered the team.  For some reason, Murph is a real polarizing player for an increasingly fickle Mets fandom.  I don’t get it, and these calls for Valdespin to take over for him at this stage are just bizarre. 
     
    That said, I hope you are right about TC being as patient with Murph as he was with Ike.  I guess I’m not as hopeful. 
     
    For some reason, Ike seems to get more of a pass from both fans and mgt when he’s not performing than Murph, which seems odd given that expectations for Ike should be much higher…

  • http://on-the-way-home.org musicom

     @MikeyJoe Thanks for your comment and I appreciate you reading! I’m glad that you enjoyed article and I agree with you. When Murph is hitting well, everyone is all over him, but when he struggles lots are looking for an alternative. I do think TC will be patient and be sure to put him in positions to succeed and get him back on track, just like he did for Ike.
     
    It is odd that Ike gets more of a pass with fans and mgmt; I guess that’s what home run power can do. Valdespin has done a great job to pick up the slack while Murph is struggling, but I’m sure once he adjusts to how he’s being pitched, he’ll be in there everyday again. Thankfully, Ike has picked it up so we don’t have to watch both of them struggle at the same time!

  • http://theBrooklynTrolleyBlogger.blogspot.com/ MikeLecolant

    I have a more simpleton theory.  Murph looks a little leaner to me.  I wonder if he lost some top bulk, for the sake of being more agile at second base?  Otherwise, great piece Matt.

  • http://on-the-way-home.org musicom

     @MikeLecolant Another good point that I didn’t think about… could play a role as well.